Which is the best everyday user from the MB line ?

[goodguy]

If you had to choose which pen from MB is the best all around every day user what would it be ?

 

Well I must admit for me the answer is easy.

I think the 146 is the best all around user.

I love the 149 and think it really is a great classic and an amazing user too but the slightly smaller size of the 146 with its simple and classic cigar shape design,balance make it simply to be one of the best and easiest pens to be used for most people.

 

There are lots of LE pens MB makes and some are as good as a 146 but for me a pen to be used must be a pen I feel comfy enough to use and not to worry to much if something happeneds to it.Since the 146 isnt an LE pen then it wouldnt break my heart as much as loosing a LE pen which is also an important factor for me and I think about when I decide which pen to use.

[enricof]

Used the 149 as my only daily writer for several years, and for me it still is "THE PEN".

 

Only drawbacks:

• it is too big to keep it in the shirt pocket (but I'm supposed to wear a suit most of the year anyway, being a salesman).
• for some kind of "on-the-fly" writing, uncapping it (or any other FP) takes too much time and can also be dangerous for the nib, so for these occasions I use something cheaper or a Pilot Capless.

I keep myself far away from LE pens of any brand (a pen is a wonderful tool, not a fetish).

 

The only kind of LE I could really understand/appreciate would be a pen made by myself (quantity = 1)...

Edited October 7, 2008 by enricof

[Bartimaeus]

I even prefer the Chopin (that's 145, I think).

When I got my first MB I wanted to take the 149, but I found it too big for me, so I felt much more comfortable with the Chopin.

Also I tend to write more readable and neatly with the 145 than with the 146s. Don't know if that is an effect of the size or the nib or both.

I still don't have a 149.

[shoppy]

MY Bernad Shaw FP, with out a doubt, I have never written so much in the few short days I have owned it.

[mproust]

I have new 146. A perfect writing pen. I use the 146 every day realy quality.

In the shop where I did buy the 149 I tried also all other FP in the same price range.

Always coming back to the MB 146. Some where better but the price was 3 times the 146.

Only the 149 was the same or better, but also big. At that moment and the price of 100 euro's more I choose the 146.

On Ebay I did get a 149 for a good price. My 149 is on his way (second hand) and I hope that it writes the same as the 149 or even better. (each FP is different).

I hope I can use the 149 also on a daily base.

Edited October 7, 2008 by mproust

[djrsf42]

I try to rotate as much as possible, but I use my 146 fp and my WE Poe ballpoint the most. I've also been using my WE Fitzgerald fp frequently, but I get a little nervous when it leaves the house.

[parker51man]

If you have large hands or getting on a bit, the 149 is perfect if you want somrthing smaller a 146. I dont think that LE's are the thing for everyday use, that means its prone to being lost and then replacement can be rather expensive, sometimes impossible. I have used my 149 for the last 12 years on a daily basis. But the choice is yours.

[Ghost Plane]

149

Right size and shape for me, even tho' I've got small hands.

[piembi]

My small, humble vintage 342.

Best performance and smoothest nib of all my MBs!

[fuchsiaprincess]

Hi Simon, how about a photo? And perhaps a review when you get a chance? Soki

[browning]

For my work a bp is more practical. I prefer the Faulkner for its looks and feel.

Browning

[QM2]

The Fitzgerald writer's edition is one of the most comfortable pens I have ever experienced. I think it is nearly as wide as the 149, but shorter.

 

Also, I have to say that I find the Bohemes surprisingly comfortable and convenient to use, despite the small size and retractable nibs.

 

https://www.fountainpennetwork.com/forum/in...showtopic=78429

 

http://queenmargot.com/boheme_triplets2.jpg

Edited October 8, 2008 by QM2

[ethernautrix]

StarWalker FP.

[penparadise]

Well, due to the sales figures of Montblanc, the #164 Classique ballpoint is the most used Montblanc pen.

But if you look only on fountain pens it is the #146 LeGrand.

[moewe]

...Andrew Carnegie 4810 with EF nib

[penmanila]

my 146 is in my daily rotation. perfect size, great nib.

[penparadise]

...Andrew Carnegie 4810 with EF nib

I can't believe that somebody can write with a cardboard cutter - I prefere an OB nib.

 

Axel

[georges zaslavsky]

Either my 1986 MB 146 with its EF smooth semi flex nib or my 1977 MB 149 fine flexible nib.

[orangesam]

My current #1 is a Chopin with fine nib, but I could be tempted by a 146, although I'm not sure if I could get used to the whole bottled ink thing! I know...I'm a pleb who uses cartridges!

 

Maybe a 147 Traveller is an option

[gregamckinney]

I don't have/use many MB's, but I have a 642-G with a fantastic OB nib that writes like a dream. It is small enough to carry easily, and is not too flashy to use regularly at work.

If I could only keep 1 MB, this would be it. If I had to pare my collection down to 10 pens, this would be one of them.

 

Regards, greg