Homage To Homer Thread

[DanD]

Well I did it!!!! I knew I should not stop by the Montblanc Boutique. I put the Homer in my hand and it felt as if it belonged there. Took a total of 5 seconds to convince myself. I think this will become my daily writer.

[Ceelo]

So I was in the boutique today to pick up a new bottle of Royal Blue ink and I was offered to handle the new Homer so I gladly accepted.

 

My initial thoughts from viewing the pen on the internet was not positive, and this was sadly reinforced in the flesh. The pen has an intricate design and most definitely has executed the motifs with flair. It felt very heavy and solid, built like a tank in fact, but I just couldn't get past the way it looked and handled. It was bulky in the hand and after what would be numerous demonstrations in the boutique the section was noticeably scratched. The design doesn't sit uncomfortable in the hand but the bulk was off-putting and the pen felt top heavy too. There was also a noticeable gap between the body and the top trim ring of the cap, closest to the montblanc peaks. The nib has a beautiful simple design and a great size. I think I'll stay with a 'pass' on this one.

Edited September 1, 2018 by CeeElle

[888007888]

Question for those who have the homer. Do you guys have a bit of space between the band at the top of the cap and the cap body. So the joint where the gold band with Greek letters joins with the black part of the cap. When I look at the pen with a light behind it I can see a bit of a gap to verify I wasnt seeing things I slid a piece of paper between the gap. Wondering if this is common with all the homers. A little disappointed the fit and finish isnt tighter than this. I love the pen but this new finding coupled with the scratched section is making me doubt montblancs build quality.

Still haven't inked mine, but pulled it out of the box and plastic wrap just now and yes ... There is a gap when I hold the pen up to the light I can see clear gaps under the top cap ring right between the spot where the cap ring starts to flow into te black resin body. Doesn't bother me. I like the design of the pen. Between the SF pen show and a few online purchases before and after the show, I haven't yet had a chance to ink this Homer.

 

As noted by others on this thread, the boutique tester pen section was completely scratched up by others capping and uncapping the pen at the store. Since I haven't unwrapped mine yet, it still has the plastic protector on the section. Knowing it will scratch up once I start using it concerns me a little because I like keeping my pens in mint condition. So hoping it doesn't bother me too much once I start using it.

 

The only pen in my collection that I actually like to get scratched is my matte black pilot vanishing point. To me it gives that pen a lot of character. Maybe I may feel the same about this Homer once inked??!? Who knows. Only time will tell. But I like the design. Not at first and from online photos. But viewing it in person a few times made me appreciate it more so than I thought it would.

[PigRatAndGoat]

I got my deposit for the pen back today. Handled the pen one more time before I told them I could not go through with the purchase. I really wish the pen did not have this scratching issue. I really like the overall design and the choice to pair it with a 149 sized nib. Hopefully next year's Writer's Edition will be just as interesting.

[mjchuang9]

I don't see any space between them in my two Homers. I don't care much about the scratches on the section either. But there are dusts embedded in the gaps on the barrel, that's what I am getting annoyed. I use a name card to clean out. Anyway the Homer is the best writer with 149 nib I own.

 

Ok. I finally see the gap. There should not have a gap, MB can do a better job.

[mitto]

Not always.

[nishantdr83]

My 0.02 cents.

 

The pen writes well. Very well. Proof is attached.

 

It scratches easy. The clip is collecting scratches without me even trying.

 

I bought the pen to use as I do with all pens I buy and so, the first cent will always trump the second.

[Sblakers]

Yeah. I am able to overlook the flaws. Having a nib with Achilles helmet on it is just too cool imo. . Plus Mike Masuyama turned my medium into a perfect wet fineish stub. Pen writes like a dream.

[DPWilliams]

My Homer arrived this morning, and I'd like to say that even the best pictures don't tell the whole story. If you are on the fence, try to see it in person. There is a tactile element, as with the Tolstoy.

Edited September 5, 2018 by DPWilliams

[888007888]

My 0.02 cents.

 

The pen writes well. Very well. Proof is attached.

 

It scratches easy. The clip is collecting scratches without me even trying.

 

I bought the pen to use as I do with all pens I buy and so, the first cent will always trump the second.

Is that a standard medium nib you have on your Homer? Lines look nice

[nishantdr83]

Is that a standard medium nib you have on your Homer? Lines look nice

OB

[daenghafez]

Just got mine with a BB nib. Havent inked yet. The pen is quite large but light. I think I like it more than my Shakespeare. Homers design may look simple but artistic.

[nishantdr83]

Congratulations... I love the tactile aspect of the pen .. running my fingers on the body of the pen does replicate the sensation of petting a horse 😉

 

Just got mine with a BB nib. Havent inked yet. The pen is quite large but light. I think I like it more than my Shakespeare. Homers design may look simple but artistic.

[BillH]

Mine came also, with a wet OM nib. Easily the largest pen in the box, and good weight, but the Tolstoy outweighs it by a bit. Very happy to have this one.

 

[Michael R.]

Nice picture :-) Mine has an OM nib as well!

Cheers

 

Michael

[888007888]

For those that have non standard F or M nibs, did each of you purchase the pens with the BB, OB, and OM nibs ... or did each of you send in your pens for a nib exchange?

 

My boutique is quoting me 2-6 months for a nib exchange so I haven't inked my F nib yet. Not sure if I should just ink it and keep it, or send it in for an exchange and just wait. I am in the USA.

 

Advice?

Edited September 8, 2018 by 888007888

[BillH]

888, I ordered mine from Appelboom on 7/26. Ordered it with the OM nib and they handled the exchange. It arrived here in Rattlesnake Junction two days ago. Easy deal. I have never sent a pen from home for a nib exchange so cannot advise on that method, sorry.

[888007888]

888, I ordered mine from Appelboom on 7/26. Ordered it with the OM nib and they handled the exchange. It arrived here in Rattlesnake Junction two days ago. Easy deal. I have never sent a pen from home for a nib exchange so cannot advise on that method, sorry.

Thank you. I'm in California and have never ordered from Appelboom before. They are overseas right? No issues with ordering from there and shipping to the USA? I've often wanted to order from European dealers but have always worried about shipping issues to the USA

[1nkulus]

888, I ordered mine from Appelboom on 7/26. Ordered it with the OM nib and they handled the exchange. It arrived here in Rattlesnake Junction two days ago. Easy deal. I have never sent a pen from home for a nib exchange so cannot advise on that method, sorry.

 

IMO, your approach is ideal esp. for US buyers.

 

Reams of happiness await.

[tpsfp]

I have ordered a few things from them and its been super easy and I havent had any problems.

 

Thank you. I'm in California and have never ordered from Appelboom before. They are overseas right? No issues with ordering from there and shipping to the USA? I've often wanted to order from European dealers but have always worried about shipping issues to the USA