Jump to content

2 Montblanc 146S With Wide Variances?



gabetjh
Rate Topic 0

Recommended Posts

i recently purchased 2 montblanc 146s both from japan.

1 is the Montblanc 146 Platinum in "Fine" nib (stated in the box with the F sticker), and another monotone nib Montblanc 146 in "Medium" nib (stated by Kingdom Note).

When i received them i believe there is an error somewhere. The platinum should be in M and the monotone nib in F/EF?

Variances between them that made me think that either one of them might be fake?

 

Monotone Nib Montblanc 146

  • White Logo on cap has slight protrusions
  • Top cap trim just stated Germany
  • No inner clip engravings
  • Bottom cap trim stated Montblanc meisterstuck no 146 (note the font differences)
  • Nib writes like EF/F but stated to be M by seller
  • piston filler
  • Feed differs
  • Skipping/Irregular Ink Flow

Platinum Montblanc 146

  • White logo on cap does not protrute
  • Top cap trim states serial number only
  • Inner clip engraving stated Made in Germany METAL
  • bottom cap trim stated Montblanc Meisterstuck (note the font differences)
  • Nib writes like M but stated to be F due to F sticker in the box
  • piston filler
  • Feed differs

oQnDRUp.jpg

 

pLKfc7u.jpg

 

rTTns6I.jpg

 

ZNCeRdJ.jpg

 

GIyyAhX.jpg

 

kn2dtNJ.jpg

 

bd37l1E.jpg

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 4
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • gabetjh

    2

  • gerigo

    1

  • BlueJ

    1

  • jslallar

    1

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

They not fake. You can usually tell a fake pen by the filling system and feed. The pens are piston filled and have the right original Montblanc feeds. One is modern and the other is an older pen with an ebonite feed.

 

The older pen is definitely an XF, while the modern pen, if labeled F is probably a fatter fine. Try flushing out the older pen to make sure the pen is completely clean and then fill with a wetter ink since the 4001 inks are super dry. Also try using different papers. See if the older pen continues to skip. The unfortunate thing about the newer pens is that they have become a lot fatter in terms of nib grinds.

Edited by gerigo
Link to post
Share on other sites

The older pen may have been graded M by the seller according to Japanese standards, where a given nominal nib grade will usually be much finer than an American or European counterpart.

Link to post
Share on other sites

They not fake. You can usually tell a fake pen by the filling system and feed. The pens are piston filled and have the right original Montblanc feeds. One is modern and the other is an older pen with an ebonite feed.

 

The older pen is definitely an XF, while the modern pen, if labeled F is probably a fatter fine. Try flushing out the older pen to make sure the pen is completely clean and then fill with a wetter ink since the 4001 inks are super dry. Also try using different papers. See if the older pen continues to skip. The unfortunate thing about the newer pens is that they have become a lot fatter in terms of nib grinds.

 

 

The older pen may have been graded M by the seller according to Japanese standards, where a given nominal nib grade will usually be much finer than an American or European counterpart.

 

Thanks for all the replies! After much observation i realize that Kingdom Note might have sneakily gave a different unit or changed the nib because the nib in the image is labelled as 14K but i received a 14C! So that is one issue down. Will contact the seller in regards to this. I believe the pen i received is XF but the pen i actually placed my order is M!

 

I read that i can try flushing out using water or i can use the ultrasonic cleaner since i have one in my office.

Link to post
Share on other sites

......................

I read that i can try flushing out using water or i can use the ultrasonic cleaner since i have one in my office.

yes to water (may even add a little soap)

and

yes to ultrasound cleaner

Enjoy your pens

Have a nice day

Junaid

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Announcements


×
×
  • Create New...