Jump to content

Pelikan Souveran M800 “ Renaissance Brown” Special Edition Review



Recommended Posts

(Pasted from the original passgae from my blog: http://minglau.blogspot.hk/2017/06/pelikan-souveran-m800-renaissance-brown.html)

 

PelikanM800RB-03.jpg

 

Pelikan Souveran M800 “ Renaissance Brown” Special Edition Review

I always tell myself that I don’t need so many fountain pens, I always tell myself that some very cheap Chinese Fountain Pens actually write quite well especially after I fine-tune them to my liking, and I always tell myself that a piston-filler pen is just a springe with a nib attached. I even always tell myself that while I like big fat pens, the M800 is too fat for my small hands.
But it turned out that when Pelikan announced the release of this M800 Special Edition, I was attracted by the promotional-photo and immediately pre-ordered it.
There’re many reasons for people to love a Pelikan, but I got my own special reason for not being able to deny this pen: The guys from Pelikan set the pen on a high-quality, classic picture frame and shot the promotional-photo! We’re in the professional Photo Printing & Framing business, that photo just made me mentally attached to this particular pen - it looks like this is THE PEN for a picture framer, the theme of this pen matches our business very well. Moreover, we do a lot of our art/photo printing jobs on Germen papers with customers’ great satisfactions. It’s natural to love German pens when we love German papers. “German-engineering”, what else?
For those who are new to the fountain pen world, here is some of my brief knowledge about Pelikan, Pelikan is the family symbol of one of the early owners, and the firm started as ink manufacturer and later switched to the production of fountain pen with a patented differential piston-filler mechanism. Like many other pen manufacturers, Pelikan underwent up and down throughout the history, and the ownership was transferred several times, but nowadays it still be able to maintain its reputation as one of the best German-quality pen manufacturers.
I think one of the formula of success of Pelikan is the periodically release of a special edition pen, and the special editions are usually based on the familiar existing models with the change of body material or colour schemes, so they don’t need to completely redesign a pen or incorporate new tooling, additional cost (and selling price) is kept low while the careful choice of the special edition materials are always stunning and impressive, and give significant differentiation to the standard product line and more importantly, maintain existing customers’ royalty, very clever. This M800 Renaissance brown is one of those.
PelikanM800RB-05.jpg
Packing
So here we go into the actual pen, though it’s a special edition, there’s nothing special with the packing, it’s exactly the same as the standard Souveran line. The pen is protected inside a white pen porch, but this is just part of the packing and nothing more than a good looking bubble-wrap replacement, the elastic band is cumbersome and won’t last long if it’s really used as a pen porch.
PelikanM800RB-02.jpg
PelikanM800RB-01.jpg
Body/Design
The basic shape of this special edition is the same as the standard M800, just that the standard black cap and the strapped celloid barrel are changed into the stunning brown acrylic. Some people argued that the beauty of an acrylic material is nowhere comparable to celluloid, I think if one’s willing to invest, one may get elegant acrylics, such as what Pelikan demonstrated in its great-looking special edition pens.
The M800 is the second largest pen in the Souveran line-up, many people suggested that it’s already too fat to grip comfortably and too back-heavy for a long writing session. I got the same feeling especially as my hands are small even for Asian’s standard. I like heavy pens, but back-balance can be a problem even if the pen is not really heavy, interestingly, the balance with the cap unposted is already bad enough that posting it doesn’t create additional badness for me. If you prefer a daily writer or a work-horse pen, perhaps stop at the M600.
As with all Souveran pens, the M800 has a golden ring at the tip of the section, it looks nice but I’m worried that the plated gold will flake off over time due to ink corrosion, it is a common problem for golden rings located that close to the nib. To slow down ink corrosion process, Iron-gall inks should be avoided, clean and dry the pen thoroughly and don’t leave it inked when you don’t plan to use it for a long time, I know, it’s easier said than done specially if you’re an ink-holic.
Additional information about iron-gall inks, quite a lot of them are blue-black inks, they are at least slightly acidic and can corrode the metal parts of a pen faster than PH neutral ink (sadly I learnt it from experience but not a book). If it’s that bad, why people like iron-gall inks? They are quite archival-safe and water resistant, together with the blue-black colour they can be the best ink for business purpose.
PelikanM800RB-04.jpg
PelikanM800RB-07.jpg
PelikanM800RB-08.jpg
PelikanM800RB-09.jpg
Filling Mechanism
Pelikan manufactured the first differential piston filler fountain pen, if a piston-filler is a must-have in your collection, the Pelikan is a must-buy. The black finial (it’s actually a very dark brown) is the piston knob, a quarter of anti-clockwise turn will trigger the brass piston mechanism. This brass piston is robust and should last for many years, it adds heft (some people including me translate a bit of heft into quality) to the M800 over its smaller siblings with plastic pistons, but it is a double-edged sword for people like me with small hands, the back-balance problem gives me some less than peasant feeling when writing.
It’s interesting to operate the piston, but the truth is, I dislike wiping a pen after dipping it into an ink bottle (and this pen is too fat form some bottles), I prefer syringe-fill me pens with no exception even for a Pelikan which is one of the best piston-fillers. Am I wasting a piston-filler in this regard? May be not, the Pelikan’s nib-unit can be screwed out easily for a quick syringe-fill. With a C/C pen, I’ll have to remove the barrel, then remove the convertor before I can do a refill, which is more troublesome.
The barrel is slightly translucent, it’s ok to hold the pen under strong back light to check the approximate ink level.
PelikanM800RB-10.jpg
Nib
The pen comes with a standard M800 medium-grade 18K gold nib, with beautiful 2 –tone nib-work. It’s a hard nib but not to the extent of a nail, It’s easy to get a bit of line variation and ink shading with ease, there is a slightly stub-characteristic for this nib. It seems to be well-known that Pelikan pens write a bit wider and wetter than many other pens of the same nib-grade, it is not the case here, I think the flow’s just average or even slightly on the dry side, for example it’s dryer than a Parker Duofold M and even a Pilot C74 F. I even compare it with a MB144 B as well, I know it’s unfair to compare M and B nibs, but the 144 is much wetter to an out-of-proportion extent. Forgot to mention, I inked it with 2 of my familiar J.herbin inks which are also in my other pens for fair comparison, I didn’t try it with Edlestein ink yet as I received mine just a week ago.
PelikanM800RB-06.jpg
My conclusion

 

The Pelikan M800 may be a bit fat and back-balance for some people to write comfortably, nevertheless it is an iconic fountain pen to be respected, and by throwing in a bit more money at the right timing, you’ll be able to avoid the standard, mass-produced M800 and get a special edition which is more unique and exciting due to the eye-catching material used. It’s not only a writing tool, but a jewel as well. If you ever come across a SE(or even a LE) and you know you want it badly, don’t wait as they will be sold out real fast.
Contact: minglau@trailstudio.com.hk
Edited by MingLau
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 23
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • MingLau

    3

  • Mr.Rene

    2

  • mamajones

    1

  • minddance

    1

Thank you for the review. I like your photos better than Pelikan's.

If you want less blah, blah, blah and more pictures, follow me on Instagram!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for a wonderful review.

 

Nice pen, even though I will not be getting one as I have two M800s (green and a red one).

 

Perhaps an M1000.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you for the review. I like your photos better than Pelikan's.

 

 

Yes, great pics and a very nice review. Thanks!

"Inspiration exists, but it has to find you working." -Pablo Picasso


Link to post
Share on other sites

Love the pen. Maybe one day. I must add, however, Pelikan nibs, except from the 1950s and back, are best sent to a nibmeister for special treatment. The original nibs, and I've had superb ones, are merely round. All of mine have written well, but not with flair and character. After Pendleton Brown finished with them, shear excitement. Strangers comment on my writing. Well, it's the nibs, not my writing. And, for finish and beauty, Pelikan is my choice.

 

Also, the M800 is balanced best for me unposted. Comfortable for lots of writing. Love your photos. I also love the M600.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Your pictures are quite simply gorgeous: that is one stunning pen! (Nothing like a professional to do the job right!)

 

Thanks for sharing with us.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 4 months later...

Thanks everyone for your reply, and sorry for not return to FPN for a while.

 

Just a bit of update about the relatively dry flow. After a few days of the review, I concluded that the nib was too dry and not preforming like a pelikan, then I decided to do a simple adjustment to widen the slit: press it a bit hard on a paper, and then rock the tines(by rocking the pen)slightly a few times. It may sound dangerous to somebody but dont worry I often play with nibs and feed (as always, do it at your own risk if you want to use this method to widen the slit :P), the pen then wrote like what a pelikan should be :)

Link to post
Share on other sites
half_inked_one

Recently I've had an opportunity to compare Renaissance Brown model to my Conway Stewart Bracket Brown (new) - and with all due respect to Pelikan, the material is not even closely as pretty. I know, piston filler etc; but CS is simply beautiful.

So, I put down M800 without regrets.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Gorgeous pen but again, premium price tag just kind of should be celluloid. If you're going to charge me as much as a celluloid pen it better be made from equivalently special materials.

 

It's the main reason I don't own a mont blanc. I adore the look of the 149, but I just don't want a simple plastic pen when I'm spending over $200. $200 is about the max I'd pay for a stunning acrylic design, maybe $350 for one with a gold nib.

 

Sure didn't stop me buying three freaking bottles of smoky quartz ink. God I love this color! I was iffy at first on the sample, wasn't too fond of it at $30/bottle, but found a seller from germany for $17/bottle and I vowed to never run out for the rest of my life.

Edited by Honeybadgers

Selling a boatload of restored, fairly rare, vintage Japanese gold nib pens, click here to see (more added as I finish restoring them)

Link to post
Share on other sites
georges zaslavsky

gorgeous pen and gorgeous craftsmaship on it, thanks for sharing

Pens are like watches , once you start a collection, you can hardly go back. And pens like all fine luxury items do improve with time

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Gorgeous pen but again, premium price tag just kind of should be celluloid. If you're going to charge me as much as a celluloid pen it better be made from equivalently special materials.

 

It's the main reason I don't own a mont blanc. I adore the look of the 149, but I just don't want a simple plastic pen when I'm spending over $200. $200 is about the max I'd pay for a stunning acrylic design, maybe $350 for one with a gold nib.

 

Sure didn't stop me buying three freaking bottles of smoky quartz ink. God I love this color! I was iffy at first on the sample, wasn't too fond of it at $30/bottle, but found a seller from germany for $17/bottle and I vowed to never run out for the rest of my life.

+1 :thumbup:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now







×
×
  • Create New...