Jump to content

Recommended Posts

vineetkgiri

HELLO FPN MEMBERS

I am a Delhi based research student who has just entered in the world of fountain pens. I purchased two fountain pens Pilot Metropolitan and Jinhao X750 from Ravi’s Pens point very recently after my disappointment with Camlin Trinity (its ink flow turned out to be terrible). I have decided I won’t upgrade to Lamy or TWSBI now. I know you guys might get be getting this a lot to the extent it might sound little banal but I am looking for budget fountain pens under 1000 INR (15 dollars). I am thinking to buy a platinum preppy soon but I really want to try some Indian fountain pens and will be glad to get some recommendations especially that are decent writers for long writing sessions. I prefer my Jinhao over my Metropolitan so I think I have a preference for a medium nib.

 

Also I have realized, a paper has a considerable impact on the performance of a fountain pen. After the recommendation by Ravi, I tried locating JK cedar 100gsm in North Delhi only to end my search in dismay (couldn’t find it anywhere in stationaries but I have not tried Nayi Sadak). The price offered by Amazon for Cedar is more than 400 INR (including delivery charges). I am looking for budget decent performing notebooks or sheets for note-making and daily writing that are good alternatives to Cedar.

 

Other issue I am facing is drying of ink in my Metropolitan. I used Ravi’s (pen point South ex) Ink with my Metropolitan but I have realized I have to shake it repeatedly otherwise it stops writing and it also dries quickly. I can’t write and read simultaneously with metropolitan’s cap dismounted. Although I didn’t face the same problem when I used Pelikan 4001 with Jinhao and the uncapped Jinhao performs decently even after I don’t put back the pen cap quickly. I think it is the drying problem of the ink and not the pen. I have used Camlin royal blue ink and found it a decent performing ink. What are other decent budget inks that don’t get dry quickly?

 

Any insights on the above issues would be appreciated.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 62
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • vineetkgiri

    25

  • vijaych

    6

  • mssethi

    4

  • tusharksingla

    4

Sasha Royale

Parker 45 fountain pens have endured many years. I see them often because I always carry one.

 

In the 1970's, my life brought me in contact with numerous young medical professionals (nurses, interns, X-ray technicians, students) from India. More than half were using Parker 45 fountain pens. Many were received as gifts from family, for the journey to America.

 

I conclude that it is (was) a very popular pen in India. A number of my vintage Parker 45 fountain pens were bought on Ebay, from sellers in India. They may be reasonably priced and plentiful.

Edited by Sasha Royale

Auf freiem Grund mit freiem Volke stehn.
Zum Augenblicke dürft ich sagen:
Verweile doch, du bist so schön !

Link to post
Share on other sites
vineetkgiri

Thanks a lot for your recommendation.Will try to find Parker 45 but I think it is a vintage pen and might not fit in my budget.

Link to post
Share on other sites
sciumbasci

How about the Camlin 47? I fell in love with it, and heard it is a school model, so might fit your requirements.

 

Otherwise, you might want to consider a Sailor HighAce Neo straight from Japan with free postage.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The Airmail Wality 69 in ebonite is an outstanding, well-proportioned, durable pen. This one is configured with a Kanwrite flex nib.

 

fpn_1494451312__rick-warren-think-less-y[/url

Reviews and articles on Fountain Pen Network

 

CHINA, JAPAN, AND INDIA

Hua Hong Blue Belter | Penbbs 456 | Stationery | ASA Nauka in Dartmoor and Ebonite | ASA Azaadi | ASA Bheeshma | ASA Halwa | Ranga Model 8 and 8b | Ranga Emperor

ITALY AND THE UK

FILCAO Roxi | FILCAO Atlantica | Italix Churchman's Prescriptor

USA, INK, AND EXPERIMENTS

Bexley Prometheus | Route 54 Motor Oil | Black Swan in Icelandic Minty Bathwater | Robert Oster Aqua | Diamine Emerald Green | Mr. Pen Radiant Blue | Three Oysters Giwa | Flex Nib Modifications | Rollstoppers

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Other issue I am facing is drying of ink in my Metropolitan. I used Ravi’s (pen point South ex) Ink with my Metropolitan but I have realized I have to shake it repeatedly otherwise it stops writing and it also dries quickly. I can’t write and read simultaneously with metropolitan’s cap dismounted. Although I didn’t face the same problem when I used Pelikan 4001 with Jinhao and the uncapped Jinhao performs decently even after I don’t put back the pen cap quickly. I think it is the drying problem of the ink and not the pen. I have used Camlin royal blue ink and found it a decent performing ink. What are other decent budget inks that don’t get dry quickly?

 

Any insights on the above issues would be appreciated.

Have you checked to see if the converter/cartridge is pushed in all the way until it clicks? It's common with the Metro. You don't mention if you're using a cartridge or a converter so I had to ask.

Having said that, the symptoms is typical from what you describe of an air bubble.

Edited by Bluey
Link to post
Share on other sites
vineetkgiri

How about the Camlin 47? I fell in love with it, and heard it is a school model, so might fit your requirements.

 

Otherwise, you might want to consider a Sailor HighAce Neo straight from Japan with free postage.

Thanks ! not sure about Camlin 47, I think it's no longer readily available and would become vintage soon. But I was looking at Camlin Elegante and have read some positive reviews about it. About Sailor HighAcne, Thanks for recommending will definitely purchase one in near future.

Link to post
Share on other sites
vineetkgiri

The Airmail Wality 69 in ebonite is an outstanding, well-proportioned, durable pen. This one is configured with a Kanwrite flex nib.

 

fpn_1494451312__rick-warren-think-less-y[/url

Thanks for recommending, Now I have so many options to consider !

Link to post
Share on other sites
vineetkgiri

Have you checked to see if the converter/cartridge is pushed in all the way until it clicks? It's common with the Metro. You don't mention if you're using a cartridge or a converter so I had to ask.

Having said that, the symptoms is typical from what you describe of an air bubble.

I am using the Aeromatic converter which comes with the Metro. I am thinking to try Metro with some different ink or do I need to use a cartridge ?

Link to post
Share on other sites
RohanOrhanHaron

For daily and cheap(price) use, I'd recommend the Camlin Presa.
It's really ergonomic and doesn't strain your hand at all.
The nib is slightly thin, but really smooth.

This is a perfect starting off pen.

This is what I use for exams and stuff, as the Extra fine nib makes the ink not bleed through on cheap university paper, even while it is super smooth.

However, don't use pigment inks in it as its feed is a Wick action based.

Buy a syringe to refill the cartridges or buy a cello fountain pen with a convertor and use it in a Presa.


http://www.amazon.in/Camlin-Presa-Cartridge-Fountain-Piece/dp/B01J1WLNF8/

Edited by RohanOrhanHaron
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

from my own personal experience of Camlin Trinity and Elegante i can say they both have scratchy nibs ..now i do understand that i dont have a ton of these pens , i have one each, so i can only base my experience off that..but stay away from them i will say.

 

i personally hate to give up on a pen , no matter how cheap. so i am willing to spend some time with a brand new pen and a magnifying loup and and nail buffer to align and smooth them ...but if you are unwilling to put up with all this hassle , then stay away from the trinity and Elegante..just go for Jinhao x450 or 500 or 250..all of them i found reliable in medium nib as commonly available, out of the box.

 

do let us know what you choose and how they are faring .

 

post-135784-0-64749800-1496513195_thumb.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1 month later...
vineetkgiri

For daily and cheap(price) use, I'd recommend the Camlin Presa.

It's really ergonomic and doesn't strain your hand at all.

The nib is slightly thin, but really smooth.

 

This is a perfect starting off pen.

 

This is what I use for exams and stuff, as the Extra fine nib makes the ink not bleed through on cheap university paper, even while it is super smooth.

 

However, don't use pigment inks in it as its feed is a Wick action based.

 

Buy a syringe to refill the cartridges or buy a cello fountain pen with a convertor and use it in a Presa.

 

 

http://www.amazon.in/Camlin-Presa-Cartridge-Fountain-Piece/dp/B01J1WLNF8/

Thanks for your suggestion, but I have decided that I would avoid using camlin for some time.

Link to post
Share on other sites
vineetkgiri

from my own personal experience of Camlin Trinity and Elegante i can say they both have scratchy nibs ..now i do understand that i dont have a ton of these pens , i have one each, so i can only base my experience off that..but stay away from them i will say.

 

i personally hate to give up on a pen , no matter how cheap. so i am willing to spend some time with a brand new pen and a magnifying loup and and nail buffer to align and smooth them ...but if you are unwilling to put up with all this hassle , then stay away from the trinity and Elegante..just go for Jinhao x450 or 500 or 250..all of them i found reliable in medium nib as commonly available, out of the box.

 

do let us know what you choose and how they are faring .

 

attachicon.gif20170603_233351.jpg

Thank you for your valuable insights, I haven't added any new pen in my collection. I am using metropolitan for my notes making. It is little scratchy but considering classmate notebook is not an ideal paper for the pen, i have kind of accustomed myself to it.

post-136747-0-20617200-1501245487_thumb.jpg

Edited by vineetkgiri
Link to post
Share on other sites
RohanOrhanHaron

Thanks for your suggestion, but I have decided that I would avoid using camlin for some time.

Understandable.

My experience with Camlin other than this has been sketchy as well. I'd still suggest giving it a try.

 

This one seems to be completely made by Ambitious, so you can expect most of the problems of the other pens to be absent:

http://ambitiousindia.com/product_detail.html?id=11&main=9

Link to post
Share on other sites
vineetkgiri

Understandable.

My experience with Camlin other than this has been sketchy as well. I'd still suggest giving it a try.

 

This one seems to be completely made by Ambitious, so you can expect most of the problems of the other pens to be absent:

http://ambitiousindia.com/product_detail.html?id=11&main=9

I will give definitely a try a some point. Which brand of ink you use for daily writing ? How is this 'ambitious pen" ? How can one purchase it? I don't think it is readily available in market. Would be glad to get feedback on these issues. I am still a novice so I don't know much about the fountain pens except those I own and the popular brands that I have heard about.

Link to post
Share on other sites
RohanOrhanHaron

I will give definitely a try a some point. Which brand of ink you use for daily writing ? How is this 'ambitious pen" ? How can one purchase it? I don't think it is readily available in market. Would be glad to get feedback on these issues. I am still a novice so I don't know much about the fountain pens except those I own and the popular brands that I have heard about.

Ambitious, being an ODM company, makes pens for others. Hence, the only available version of the pen is Camlin Presa, as far as I have been to find out.

For daily writing, I have been using Daytone calligraphy blue. I have found it proper only with extra fine nibs, such as the Presa, as it spreads more (though doesn't feather) and it is good enough to use even on the (bleep) University exam papers.

However, on Jowo fine nib, it would spread a lot and hence bleed-through.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

Ambitious, being an ODM company, makes pens for others. Hence, the only available version of the pen is Camlin Presa, as far as I have been to find out.

For daily writing, I have been using Daytone calligraphy blue. I have found it proper only with extra fine nibs, such as the Presa, as it spreads more (though doesn't feather) and it is good enough to use even on the (bleep) University exam papers.

However, on Jowo fine nib, it would spread a lot and hence bleed-through.

Thanks for your valuable feedback!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just saw this thread. I can understand your problems. Have a Camlin Trinity that is almost better at being a dart than a pen, but I'll fix it some day. As a suggestion why not look at a Camlin 22 eyedropper. They are reasonably inexpensive and hold a fair amount of ink and write tolerably well.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

Just saw this thread. I can understand your problems. Have a Camlin Trinity that is almost better at being a dart than a pen, but I'll fix it some day. As a suggestion why not look at a Camlin 22 eyedropper. They are reasonably inexpensive and hold a fair amount of ink and write tolerably well.

I recently used a Trinity that was owned by one of my friends. I was surprised to see the smoothness of the pen. I don't know much repairing fountain pens so can't do much about it. But would definitely want to replace the nib, if possible the feed too. Are there any nibs or feed that are compatible with Camlin Trinity?

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

I do not know for certain but Fountain Pen Revolution sells #5 and #5.5 nibs for next to nothing that may fit in the Trinity. They also have options in sizes up to flex. May be worthwhile taking a look on the web.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Announcements


×
×
  • Create New...