Jump to content
Classifieds is broken, please do not submit any new ads ×

Porsche Design P'3100 Fountain Pen Review


Letrow
 Share

Recommended Posts

This is a short review of the Porsche Design P'3100 fountain pen.

 

16598907572_3760df70c6_c.jpg

 

The P'3100 comes in a nice looking black box, probably cardboard covered with some synthetic material. Nice, but not comparable to the luxury boxes that some other fountain pens come in.

The pen looks big and somehow technical, probably of the cable design and the little spring-loaded dots at the bottom of the pen. The material is TecFlex, a stainless steel borrowed from motor racing, which provides the unique weaved pattern. My motorcycle has something which is similar, so I quite like this. The pen feels really smooth and although it is quite heavy, it feels very comfortable when you hold it for writing. The nib is ... well different. The Pd mark can be clearly read whether the pen is held up or down and the other text on the pen (750 M 18 ct) is upside down compared to what most other fountain pens have.

 

On the cap it says Porsche Design and Germany and the nib has the markings as described above. Apart from that the bottom half, once unscrewed, shows the number 201 in black. I am not sure what that stands for.

 

The metal parts on the pen are covered with a layer of palladium, to give it a silky finish and the material is said (by Porsche Design) to be hard wearing and almost everlasting. We'll see about that ;-).

The nib is 18 ct gold and rhodinized.

 

The clip looks pretty common and is spring-loaded. It has a bit of move to the left and right, but feels quite sturdy. The cap comes off with a short quarter turn. I like screw on caps, but usually the turn is longer (e.g. the turn on the TWSBI is about a full turn and a bit).

 

16573485416_85b9281aef_c.jpg

 

Compared to the TWSBI Diamond 580 the Porsche Design pen is slightly bigger and definitely heavier when picked up.

 

This is the stainless steel version of the pen. It is also available in a weave of gold and stainless steel and in black. I am not a fan of black and gold and stainless steel might be a bit too flashy for my taste, so I am quite happy with this material.

The pen feels nice and cool to the touch and the overall impresion is one of quality and smoothness or silkyness. I am not sure about how well the weave pattern is dirt resistant and once dirty it might prove difficult to clean.
I am not sure why you would do it, but if you drop this pen it can probably stand a lot of abuse.

When the bottom half is unscrewed you see that the bottom half is all metal on the inside. The weave covers that and the combination makes it a big pen. Both bottom half and nib section are stainless steel and both parts feel heavy. The screw thread here takes about 5-6 turns to unscrew, much more than the cap needs. The screw thread on the nib section is covered entirely and not immediately visible, a nice touch.
16598289751_7fa6a4a66f_c.jpg

The pen has a good grip, the palladium providing me with enough resistance. Towards the nib the grip narrows a bit, so depending on hand size I think a lot of people can hold this pen comfortably.
Writing is incredibly smooth. I am pretty enthusiastic about my old S.T. Dupont Classique pen which is smooth, but this is much smoother.
The 18 ct nib is covered with rhodium (Rh), a member of the platinum group, just like palladium. It is silvery-white, very hard and chemically inert. Its resistance to corrosion makes it suitable for fountain pens. You all know this of course.

 

This is a modern looking pen, but at the same time you know you have something of a classic at hand here, because of its unique look and the material used.

The pen moves over any paper in an effortless way. I like to use it uncapped, but even when capped (the cap is secured by pushing it over the three pins on the bottom half) the balance is very good. The pen does not realy feel too heavy even then. It might be because both nib section and bottom half are quite weighty, it keeps the balances in check.

The nib is a Medium size, on the narrower side of medium. Very pleasant to use, just right for me. The nib is made of 18 ct gold, covered with rhodium as I said before and has 750, M and 18ct stamped on it, upside down. The nib doesn't have a hole on top, it is just cut. Ink flow is without any problems. The nib is broad and looks massive.

The underside is ribbed, nothing really stands out there.

 

15977309204_f79232f35b_c.jpg

 

As I understand it, these pens are designed by Porsche Design and produced by Graf von Faber-Castell. The pen takes the international cartridges or the Graf von Faber-Castell converters.
As far as I know I can't easily remove this nib to service it or replace it. I'd go through a service centre in all probability.

16598870092_e662f9de8d_c.jpg

 

From the writing example you can see that the pen does not have any hiccups in terms of ink flow. Writing is very smooth as I said before and this might be the one point that some people like less about the pen. If you like a bit of resistance in your writing, this might be too smooth for you. For me it works, but I do notice that my letters come out slightly less clean-cut than with the TWSBI.

I bought this pen about 170 euro. Not really cheap, but I feel it is good value for the money paid.

 

A review of the other pen I mentioned above, the S.T. Dupont Classique can be found here.

Edited by Letrow
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 13
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • hari317

    2

  • mitto

    1

  • JanKafka

    1

  • praxim

    1

It's a fine pen, though I can't help but think that for most of the Porsche Design lines the fountain pens are an afterthought. The ballpoints and pencils incorporate the materials into their function, like using the tech-flex as a spring to deploy the point, while for the fountain pens it is purely aesthetic, which is a little disappointing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the review. I like the weaving on the barrel. However, the nib, in terms of looks, doesn't look very exciting enough to lighten my wallet. :)

http://img5.imageshack.us/img5/4992/fpnpcex150.jpg
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 years later...

Nice. I have the older gold-steel version of this pen which has a different nib imprint. Very well made.

In case you wish to write to me, pls use ONLY email by clicking here. I do not check PMs. Thank you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Nice. I have the older gold-steel version of this pen which has a different nib imprint. Very well made.

 

Can you tell us what the 'gold' threads on the barrel are made of? Many websites just list them as gold threads, indicating that these are made of real gold, but I can't see how they can achieve this at this price point. Unless of course it is made of like 1/50 of 9k gold. Thanks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Can you tell us what the 'gold' threads on the barrel are made of? Many websites just list them as gold threads, indicating that these are made of real gold, but I can't see how they can achieve this at this price point. Unless of course it is made of like 1/50 of 9k gold. Thanks.

I don't know. The gold is most probably plated as there is no separate hallmark on the wires.

In case you wish to write to me, pls use ONLY email by clicking here. I do not check PMs. Thank you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share








×
×
  • Create New...