I agree with you. I love that Noodler's pushes the inky envelope. That being said, Purple People Eater, Navajo Turquoise and Midway Blue will always be part of my ink collection.
I had a new bottle of ummmmm..... Fontslanc red ink and I couldn't give it away to 5 FP devotees. I could have sold for it as runny cherry Kool-Aid.
And kudos to ummmmm.... Fontslanc for delivering excellent inks and marketing ideas with their inks over the last 5 years...