Registration on the Fountain Pen Network
Due to the enormous influx of spammers, it is no longer possible to handle valditions in the traditional way. For registrations we therefore kindly and respectfully request you to send an email with your request to our especially created email address. This email address is register at fountainpennetwork dot com. Please include your desired user name, and after validation we will send you a return email containing the validation key, normally wiithin a week.
Thank you very much in advance!
The FPN Admin Team
FPN Quick Navigation
- Our New FPN 2015 LE Pen!
- - FPN Blue Pearl Celebration LE
- FPN Forums & Forum Categories
- - FPN News forum
- - The Mall forum
- - FPN World forums
- - The Marketplace Forums
- - Writing Instruments forums
- - Brand Focus forums
- - Regional Focus forums
- - Inks, Inc. forums
- - Paper, & Pen Acc. forums
- - Creative Expressions forums
- FPN Store, Donations, Accounts & Advertising
- - Store Home
- - FPN Ink Store
- - Advertise on FPN - Info
- - FPN Marketing & Advertising
- - Variable Amount Donations - Iridium, Rhodium & Platinum
- - Fixed Amount FPN Rhodium & Platinum Supporters, & FPN without Ads Donations
- - Premium (Trader/Retailer) Accounts
- - Straight PayPal Anonymous Donations
- - FPN Without Ads Donation, Annual Subscription
- - FPN Without Ads Donation, Monthly Subscription
- - The FPN Café Press Shop
- FPN Apps & Modules
- - Blogs
- - Classifieds
- - Gallery
- - Downloads
- - Home Page
- - Members
- - Pen Events Calendar
- - FPN's RSS Feeds
- - Shoutbox
- - Upload
- - Classifieds: Browsing
- - Classifieds: Creation
- - Classifieds: Questions & Answers
- - Upload: How-to
- Rules & Guidelines
- - FPN Rules, Guidelines, TOU
- - Classifieds Rules
- - Premium Accounts: Rules
- - Market Watch Rules
Refom 1745 Vs Pelikan M200
Posted 21 December 2011 - 21:00
Out of the box:
The Pelikan comes with a nice display box and with papers. The Reform comes with nothing, unless you buy them by the case. They come in cardboard boxes of 24 and nowhere on the packaging does it say that size the nibs are.
Design and Appearance:
The M200 only comes in black, pictured, at the time of writing. It has come in various colours including marbled blue or green (rumored to be returning) -with the striped bodies reserved for the M400s of the same size. Variants include M205s (at time of writing) have silver trim and are available in black, red and white, as well as a special yellow/demonstrator highlighter edition; M215 which have metal bodies as opposed to the M200's plastic/resin; and M250 which come with the bi-colour gold nib from the M400. The Pelikan clips across most of the Pelikan range are a pelican's beak.
The Reform 1745 is more basic, with fewer options, It comes in green with a black caps and section. I have seen photos of a similar pen in blue, but never seen one. The firm apparently folded in 1993 with some NOS left around. Both pen's seem to be made of a nice enough quality materials, with the Pelikan's trim being of a higher standard.
(Pelikan M200 left, Reform 1745 right)
PR side by side by Bigeddie100, on Flickr
Feel and Construction:
Both pens feel well constructed, if light due to their mostly plastic construction. Mostly full, the M200 - 15g, the 1745 10g. Their length is about the same, both capped 13cm and posted 15cm, if anything the 1745 is a little longer than the M200. The M200 is also noticeably wider than the reform, although posted neither seems like a small pen.
PR side by side rule by Bigeddie100, on Flickr
PR side by side posted by Bigeddie100, on Flickr
Both pens have an ink viewing window to gauge the level of ink. In black, the M200's is not too clear, although in other colours the ink level is more visible.
Nibs and writing performance:
Both have removable nibs, both screw fit, although the nibs of the 1745 are not labelled, if indeed they ever came in different sizes. The Pelikan nibs are available in EF, F, M, B, BB, OM and OB sizes. The one sampled here is an F.
Both the pen's have steel nibs. The nib on the 1745 writes most like a fine, slightly finer than the M200. The M200's nib is gold plated and states the size, the 1745's is duo-tone but there is no real indication of the plating material, the The 1745's nib is also more flexible than the Pelikan's, surprisingly so.
PR pel nib by Bigeddie100, on Flickr
PR reform nib by Bigeddie100, on Flickr
Writing samples with both pens
PR writing sample by Bigeddie100, on Flickr
In terms of writing, both put down a nice fine line, neither is particularly wet, I use two different 1745's, one was very dry 'out of the box' (well, post packet) which was solved by pushing the pen to the limit I would consider flexing the nib a few times. The gently pushing the tines apart trick didn't have the same effect where the 1745's nib was so flexible.
The Pelikan was purchased from The Writing Desk (no affil) in the UK for around £50 inc. postage. The Reform for £13.50 inc. postage on e-bay. They can be had cheaper (£8) NOS in the classifies at the time of writing. I think the reform's are tremendously good value, I always keep my pens in a case, but this is one I wouldn't be heart broken if it got scratched up in a pocket.
The 'if I could have just one' winner is the Pelikan, but it is 4 to 5 times the price. It's things like the smooth piston that show. That said the nib on the Reform is fantastic. Ultimately of course, it's a matter of taste.
Disclosure; I have some Reform 1745's on classified currently - I have tried not to let this bias my review.
Posted 22 December 2011 - 20:00
Edited by Bill C, 22 December 2011 - 20:12.
Posted 23 December 2011 - 06:19
i have the 1745 and an M150 -not the 200- and i also chose the Pelikan over the Reform. i've always found the Reform's nib to be too scratchy for my liking.
Posted 23 December 2011 - 17:50
Posted 25 December 2011 - 23:58
Parker 45 F, Lamy Safari EF, Lamy 2000 F, TWSBI Diamond 530 F, Reform 1745 F,
Posted 06 February 2012 - 03:46