Registration on the Fountain Pen Network
Due to the enormous influx of spammers, it is no longer possible to handle valditions in the traditional way. For registrations we therefore kindly and respectfully request you to send an email with your request to our especially created email address. This email address is register at fountainpennetwork dot com. Please include your desired user name, and after validation we will send you a return email containing the validation key, normally wiithin a week.
Thank you very much in advance!
The FPN Admin Team
FPN Quick Navigation
- Our New FPN 2015 LE Pen!
- - FPN Blue Pearl Celebration LE
- FPN Forums & Forum Categories
- - FPN News forum
- - The Mall forum
- - FPN World forums
- - The Marketplace Forums
- - Writing Instruments forums
- - Brand Focus forums
- - Regional Focus forums
- - Inks, Inc. forums
- - Paper, & Pen Acc. forums
- - Creative Expressions forums
- FPN Store, Donations, Accounts & Advertising
- - Store Home
- - FPN Ink Store
- - Advertise on FPN - Info
- - FPN Marketing & Advertising
- - Variable Amount Donations - Iridium, Rhodium & Platinum
- - Fixed Amount FPN Rhodium & Platinum Supporters, & FPN without Ads Donations
- - Premium (Trader/Retailer) Accounts
- - Straight PayPal Anonymous Donations
- - FPN Without Ads Donation, Annual Subscription
- - FPN Without Ads Donation, Monthly Subscription
- - The FPN Café Press Shop
- FPN Apps & Modules
- - Blogs
- - Classifieds
- - Gallery
- - Downloads
- - Home Page
- - Members
- - Pen Events Calendar
- - FPN's RSS Feeds
- - Shoutbox
- - Upload
- - Classifieds: Browsing
- - Classifieds: Creation
- - Classifieds: Questions & Answers
- - Upload: How-to
- Rules & Guidelines
- - FPN Rules, Guidelines, TOU
- - Classifieds Rules
- - Premium Accounts: Rules
- - Market Watch Rules
Nakaya Writer Portable, Flexible Medium Nib
Posted 21 December 2011 - 15:05
By chance I happened to win a Platinum 3776 with a soft-fine nib on eBay after submitting just one bid. Whilst the pen was a good writer, my conclusion of the Platinum was that it was a pen with an excellent nib let down by slightly poor build quality and a body that was too short for my hand. I expected that a Nakaya, with a custom-ground nib, would be even better and so started looking around the Nakaya website and submitted an order with my writing preferences for the nib.
I got buyer’s remorse almost immediately after submitting the order and was sort of hoping that Nakaya did not get back to me. After two days (1 more than their pledge) a Nakaya lady got back to me with the payment instructions, I hesitantly paid as it did not feel right to tell her I wanted to back down.
After a 4 week wait, I got the email from Nakaya that the pen was on its way. I had been expecting them to reconfirm my writing preferences during that time but they did not . Thus I can only assume that the pen was made to my preferences.
Appearance & Design (6/10)
The pen arrived in a very nice package that has already been photographed many times for numerous other reviews on FPN.
I had originally ordered the pen in the Aka-tamenuri colour but changed to plain black to cheap skate USD100 for a pen that I was unsure whether I would like.
My first impressions of the plain black pen was that it was…er… plain.
The pen is cigar shaped and, capped, actually looks a bit like a MB 146 minus the gold rings. The Nakaya’s only source of gold bling is the clip. Afficionados or blingless pens can order this pen without the clip.
The black urushi is not particularly glossy unless held under light.
When uncapped, the pen reveals a heavily stepped section. This design allows for the cap to be the same width as the barrel to enhance the capped appearance of the pen but, to my eyes, makes the pen less attractive when uncapped. For example the MB146, with a section and barrel of similar width, looks nicer.
The nib of the pen is a nice shape but not elaborately engraved like some of the European nibs. The nib on my Nakaya was ordered in monotone and hence, not much bling here either.
I was not stunned by the looks of my particular pen but it should be noted that the same model can be dressed up in other urushi options and a two-tone nib. Had I chosen these options, at extra expense, I am sure the pen would have looked much better.
Construction & Quality (9/10)
Nakayas are hand-made and immaculately put together. I have not detected any blemish in the urushi. The cap screws onto the barrel very securely and accurately – there is no play or resistance whatsoever.
The seam on the top of the cap is almost invisible unless inspecting up-close.
Unscrewing the barrel shows the converter, which I think is a standard Platinum converter. The fit and finish of the barrel screw is also perfect. No complaints here.
The feeder is plastic. I had hoped it was ebonite since I know that Platinum does sell some 3776’s with ebonite feeds.
The only complaint I have in the build-quality of the pen is with the nib surface. Under close inspection, I can see some minor scratches on the surface that must have been inflicted during the grinding.
Weight & Dimensions (7/10)
The statistics for the pen(s) are obtained from the Nakaya website.
This pen looks and feels very similar to a Montblanc 146, with both weighing at around 15g uncapped. At 149mm long when capped, it is actually slightly longer than the MB149 but uncapped it is 128mm from nib to barrel tip vs MB146’s 126mm.
Both the Nakaya and MB146 have a maximum diameter of 15mm but it should be noted that the MB146’s cap is wider than its barrel and hence the barrel of the Nakaya is actually slightly wider than the MB146.
As mentioned before, the Nakaya has a section significantly narrower than the barrel and so does, to me, does not feel as nice to grip as that of the MB146.
Another major point to note is that the space for gripping the section is rather limiting. If one holds the pen at the bottom of the section, the urushi is actually quite slippery. If one holds higher up near the screw threads, the wider barrel ledge gets in the way to prevent a secure grip. This is a major gripe I have with this pen. (The section is longer on the long version of this pen and so affords more space for gripping the pen but one would also need to put up with a vastly longer overall pen, 163mm vs 149mm).
Nib & Performance (7/10)
I bought this pen with a flexible medium nib. The line thickness is thinner than my MB149 fine and around the same as my Montegrappa Miya fine.
The nib was smooth but initially had some tooth that seems to have gone away after breaking in. The nib writes in a bouncy way similar to Pelikan M1000 nibs but does not have much tine spread. Hence although the nib can produce line-variation, the result is not worth the effort. I guess the EF or EEF version of this nib might have more pronounce line-variation but I do not think that these nibs have that intrinsic flex capability found in vintage Pelikan nibs, for example.
Ink flow from the nib is average – neither wet nor dry – and allows a wide variety of inks to be used.
To sum up, although smooth, I do not see anything special about Nakaya nibs. I guess that run-of-the-mill Platinum nibs are just as smooth.
Filling System & Maintenance (7/10)
This pen uses a standard Platinum converter. I have no preference for piston-fillers and so am satisfied with the filling system.
Cost & Value (7/10)
This particular model has a standard retail price of USD450. For that money, you get a hand-made pen made out of ebonite and lacquered with urushi. Is it worth the money? If you consider a Pilot Custom 845 with a retail price of around USD500 reasonable, then the Nakaya is definitely good value for money. For me, not having any strong attraction to urushi or ebonite, I would prefer to spend the money on something else if I could choose again.
This Nakaya Writer is a nicely made pen that writes smoothly. It is not a good-looker but that is more to do with my own choice of options rather than the pen’s fault. I suppose this pen would appeal to someone looking for a good writer that would not attract any attention.
Unfortunately it does not do much for me.
Posted 21 December 2011 - 15:36
I think that if you are not satisfied with the nib, you should contactpeople at Nakaya and tell tehm. The fact the nib does have scratches is not acceptable for a new pen. My guess is that if the pen is not to your liking, you might be able to change it for a pen better suited for your needs - Nakaya sells the Equilibrium model that doesn't have any step and with a larger section.
free 70 pages graphic novel. Enjoy!
Posted 21 December 2011 - 16:47
Posted 21 December 2011 - 19:49
I do appreciate your well-considered review. I agree with Soot who suggested selling it and buying a different pen. With Nakaya, especially a new one, you wouldn't lose much money (if any).
Posted 21 December 2011 - 23:06
I did not really notice those scratches until very recently and maybe the pen has been in my possession for too long for Nakaya to accept responsibility now. I'll check with Nakaya anyway.
Posted 21 December 2011 - 23:27
Posted 22 December 2011 - 00:33
Posted 22 December 2011 - 05:21
Posted 22 December 2011 - 07:16
Posted 22 December 2011 - 15:43
Posted 22 December 2011 - 17:41
Just curious, had you considered buying it through nibs.com? If so, why not, since John definitely does grind/tweak the nib for your writing style?
Glenn (love those pen posses)
Posted 22 December 2011 - 21:07
I had a chance to try a Nakaya flex F nib at a show recently, and I agree with jandrese that it is much more a soft nib than a flexible one, in the sense that we use the word here on FPN. It had a lovely feel if you pressed down while writing, but the pressure change didn't result in much line variation. Still, the pens are beautiful, I think in part because when I look at one I can't help thinking that master craftsmen made this pen with their own hands, and I see it differently than I would see an (honestly) identical pen that came from a machine. Congratulations on summoning up the courage to make the purchase, and I hope you either come to love the pen for what it is, or find a way to replace it with something you love more.
Posted 22 December 2011 - 22:27
I definitely sympathize with you over your purchase. A Nakaya is quite an expensive item to not be satisfied with. I too would like to eventually purchase a Nakaya, but after reading this, I think I will purchase one from a Pen Show, where I have the opportunity to try it first.
I hope you find a buyer or a trade you will enjoy more.
WTB: Omas 360 Rollerballs
Please PM me if you have one you'd like to sell. Thank you!
Posted 22 December 2011 - 23:05
Signum1, some Platinum pens having direct equivalents at Nakaya that I like is briarwood model. I would pay the premium for a Nakaya for that model. Maybe sometime in future.
tenney, I’m in Hong Kong and shipping from Japan is USD11 vs USD32? from USA. On the Nakaya ordering form they ask you a few questions on how you hold the pen etc and I assume that their craftsmen do grind the nibs differently according to the specified preferences just like John would.
All others, yes I do agree that it is so important to try out pens first but in this day and age, it is often difficult to find the pens we want in local shops and so buy over the internet. Of all the pens I acquired recently, I have only written with 4 at a shop prior to buying.
Posted 22 December 2011 - 23:48
I love my Nakaya, but they are not for everyone. Having said that, my Nakaya is the Long version, and one of my favorite parts is the section. Its long and tapers to a width that is perfect for my grip. The next Nakaya I've planned to get a very similar to yours, albeit with different nib and clip color options, but I've been concerned about the section on the Portable, since its shorter and stouter then the section on my long. Your dissatisfaction gives me pause regarding my purchase, and for that I thank you.
I might end up with another long, or a neo standard. I just need something with a clip that I can carry.
Posted 23 December 2011 - 02:35