Now it's review time! After using the pen for a little bit tonight I wanted to give my first impression review. After a few weeks I'll do an update once the honeymoon stage has worn off, although I don't think that will ever happen with this pen .
Appearance & Design (10) – The pen is a bit lighter of a black than I imagined, the swirl of blue and black take on a wood-like appearance. I totally understand what people were saying about different light causing the pen to have a different look to it. I think the Edison logo is brilliant and it sure adds a nice touch to the nib. The grip section of the pen is exactly what I wanted in a pen. After using Lamy's horrid grip on the Al-Star I am so glad that I can place my fingers however I please, but unlike the Wality there is a small notch that your fingers rest nicely in.
Construction & Quality (10) – Brian is an expert craftsman and this pen really shows off his skills as a pen maker, what more can I say.
Weight & Dimensions (10) – The pen is about the same size as my Lamy Al-Star and Wality (see picture below). I guess all my pens are large so I don't have anything smaller to compare it to besides a Pilot V-Pen which I usually use posted. The Edison is definitely a pen I will be using un-posted, which I prefer. It balances wonderfully in the hand and is a joy to write with in that respect.
Nib & Performance (10) – I ordered the Edison with two nibs, a fine and a broad. The fine was already in the pen so that is what I chose to use for the review. Compared to the fine nib in the Wality 69L I have, this pen is a dream. On some cheap rough-textured drawing paper I use for a journal the pen is smooth, on a Rhodia dot pad the pen glides along. The pen has such a nice blend of smoothness with just the slightest feedback to let you know that you are writing, I love that. I am really looking forward to using the broad nib and in the update I'll add some information about that nib too. The ink I used was Noodler's Black which was new to me and I see why everyone loves it. Probably not a good idea using a new ink for the review of a new pen, but I couldn't resist trying that out too.
Filling System & Maintenance (10) - I am not a huge fan of the cartridge converter filling system, but I think that is just my lack of experience filling them so I think it would be unfair of me to score the pen lower based on that. Anyways, the cartridge converter in the Edison is really solid and a step up from the Lamy one I have in the AL-Star. It also looks like it will hold more ink too, but I haven't been able to test this yet.
Cost & Value (10) – At $200 I really think this pen is a steal. Being a limited edition piece like it is I am a little worried to take it anywhere, but I do plan on using it as my daily writer while at home. For school I think I'll use my cheaper pens because loosing the Edison would be like loosing a work of art.
Conclusion (10/10) - I kinda hate giving the first pen I review a perfect score, but this pen truly deserves it. The quality Brian has achieved, especially for pen of this price is incredible, not to mention it was handmade! It is certainly the most enjoyable pen I have to use. My other pens, while decent writers, all have these little quirks about them that bug me. That isn't the case at all with the Edison.
P.S. I didn't want to double post all of the pictures I already put up so if you want to see more pictures of the pen I have some in the other thread I started here (http://www.fountainp...-arrived-today/)
Edited by Robinhood, 13 July 2011 - 18:33.