Varuna Rajan VS Platignum No. 5

[crowdog]

So, I usually eschew these types of threads, when someone wants an answer for cheap pens etc, that have been answered. But after much searching, I couldn't find a good review that compared these two pens.

 

I am looking at size, length and circumference, as well as classic fountain pen "looks". Also smooth writing. I like a wet pen, I have decided, with a broader type nib. I know that the Rajan is a fine point.

 

Thanks in advance.

 

Marty

[AllWriteNow]

Hi Marty

I can't help with the comparison.

I would like to mention that the Varuna pens come with the option of upgrading to a JoWo German nib.

Available sizes are Fine, Medium and Broad. Cost is a very reasonable $15.00 usd

Installation of a Cross converter is also available for $8.00

 

Thank you

 

Steve

[crowdog]

Hi Marty

I can't help with the comparison.

I would like to mention that the Varuna pens come with the option of upgrading to a JoWo German nib.

Available sizes are Fine, Medium and Broad. Cost is a very reasonable $15.00 usd

Installation of a Cross converter is also available for $8.00

 

Thank you

 

Steve

 

Thanks Steve, you can tell me what the circumference is, in real terms. I have a Sheaffer Calligraphy pen, is it close to that?

 

Marty

[QM2]

IMO the pens are completely incomparable. The Varuna is a large handmade ebonite pen; it is very organic and there is some variance from one pen to another. The Platignum is a small, metal, mass produced pen - just a different animal entirely. Being ebonite, the Varuna is lighter in weight than the Platignum despite its larger size. At least for me, the Varuna is much more comfortable to hold.

 

As for nibs, that really depends on what you think of as Fine vs Medium vs Broad; this is very subjective. But I believe that All Write Now can find a wider nib for you if that's what you want.

 

But in any case, the pens belong in such different categories, that I really cannot say which is better for your needs.

[AllWriteNow]

Marty

I have no idea of the circumference of a Sheaffer Calligraphy pen.

 

The Rajan is .629"/15.98cm diameter.

 

Steve

[QM2]

I don't know the exact circumference, but the Varuna Rajan is definitely wider.

Hope this helps.

[crowdog]

I don't know the exact circumference, but the Varuna Rajan is definitely wider.

Hope this helps.

 

Thanks finally figured out the width by going to a ring sizing store online. Then I figured out, how to measure it out. It is huge:) It looks to be about the zize of the highlighter I have, which will be sweet.

 

Now I just have to work out the details with the wife. Steve, I will be using the inquiry form on your website, to ask a couple of questions.

 

Marty

[welch]

I have one of the Steve's pens. The (german?) medium nib is superbly smooth. I got it in the natural finish, which feels alive (almost).

 

I also own a Platignum 5, soft-grip, deep blue. Good looking pen that doesn't write so well. In a different league.

[crowdog]

Thanks everyone, you all confirmed my suspicions, and have sent off an inquiry to Dave.