QUOTE (fountainbel @ Feb 26 2006, 01:03 AM)
QUOTE (tryphon @ Feb 25 2006, 11:35 PM)
One of the advantages of shellac is that it is removable. I hope the previous repair person did not use nail polish, like so many do....
Giovanni,
Please explain why using transparent nail polish as a sac-sealant is problematic.
Even Frank Dubiel recommends in" Da Book" nail polish being a valuable sac-sealing alternative.
Thanks in advance for your clarification !
Let me start by saying that Frank Dubiel was a friend and I really miss him. We often debated on pen-related issues in many forums, always with mutual respect. We also shared a passion for wide-screen cinema and we both wrote articles and posts about that subject, as well as pens. The last time I saw him, just days before his untimely passing, he asked me to describe to him how to replace the piston seal in a vintage Aurora 88: he was going to add that process to the next edition of his repair manual.
Having said that, one must remember that his book was written at a time when proper repair supplies were hard to come by and he often offers methods that are back-ups he adopted years ago because of the lack of the ideal product or because they offered a less expensive solution (he was a thrifty person).
Having said that, here are my reasons for not using nail polish:
1. Nail polish contains acetone. Acetone emits fumes that can affect several plastics and that are very aggressive to celluloid. I do not want those fumes in an small-volume enclosed space like the inside of a pen barrel.
2. Nail polish does not soften at relatively low temperatures as shellac does. Shellac's application is easily reversible.
3. Removing dried nail polish from a sac nipple is not as easy and risk-free as removing shellac. One often needs a small file and that means taking away some nipple material.
4. Some nail polishes craze with age and turn into a fine powder that ceases to have an adhesive effect on the sac and can actually clog a feed.
Gioven all this and given the fact that some excellent shellac-based sac cements are now easily available from several sources, I do not encourage the use of nail polish in pen repair.
The picture shows Frank Dubiel and I intent on discussing cartridge pens: