Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: All the MB scented inks
The Fountain Pen Network > Reviews and Articles > Ink Reviews > Ink Comparisons, Scans and Tests
Darius
These are all the MB scented inks that I know of. If you know of any I didn't include, please let me know about it, as I would like to try it.
For larger images of scans, click on the link below each image.

Click to view attachment
Enlarge

Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Enlarge

Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Enlarge

Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Enlarge

Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Enlarge

Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Enlarge

Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Enlarge

These are all the inks on Elco Classic Verge paper, which is a heavy (100gm2) paper
Click to view attachment
Enlarge

and on Elco Record, which is a little better than the average office paper
Click to view attachment
Enlarge

and on inkjet printing paper
Click to view attachment
Enlarge

Water resistance test. The inks were left to dry for 2 hours, then the paper was put under running water.
Inks in the following order; Sakura, Je t'aime, Love You, Season's Greeting 2005, 2006, and 2007
Click to view attachment
Enlarge
The Sakura was all but gone. Both Love Letter inks completely disappeared. All three Season's Greeting inks left a legible line, but lost most of their colour.

I hope this was useful, and as I said; if anyone knows of any other MB scented ink that I didn't include, please let me know.
QM2
Very cool. Comparative reviews are so informative and useful for everyone, thank you for doing this. I am amazed that you've managed to get all of these inks, too!

QM2
hardyb
Excellent review! Thanks for all the effort. Beau.
Darius
QUOTE (QM2 @ Jul 26 2008, 06:59 PM) *
Very cool. Comparative reviews are so informative and useful for everyone, thank you for doing this. I am amazed that you've managed to get all of these inks, too!

QM2

I'm glad that you think it's useful. I've buying these inks as they were released. I had a hard time getting the Sakura ink, since it was exclusive to the Japanese market.

QUOTE (hardyb @ Jul 26 2008, 07:05 PM) *
Excellent review! Thanks for all the effort. Beau.

You're welcome.
Pravda
Darius you are the coolest person in the world..!!! smile.gif

Thanks for the reviews.. I only have the scented ink of 2006 and my the color online does not do it justice its amazing.. deep rich dark red writes beautifully.


Darius
QUOTE (Pravda @ Jul 26 2008, 09:42 PM) *
Darius you are the coolest person in the world..!!! smile.gif

Thanks for the reviews.. I only have the scented ink of 2006 and my the color online does not do it justice its amazing.. deep rich dark red writes beautifully.

Thanks for the compliment. I know what you mean. All the inks look better in real life than on the scans.
pakmanpony
Wow great review. I have the original Love letter red and Seasons greetings Cookies and spice. Does anyone know of a source for the Seasons greetings Cinnamon or Vanilla????
Darius
QUOTE (pakmanpony @ Jul 26 2008, 10:02 PM) *
Wow great review. I have the original Love letter red and Seasons greetings Cookies and spice. Does anyone know of a source for the Seasons greetings Cinnamon or Vanilla????

Thanks.

If you live in the States, then you can order online from the MB refill site. Also, many pen shops carry the inks.
pakmanpony
Thanks! I found it. Montblanc Refill Shop https://refills.montblanc.com
FieryPhoenix
Thank you for the comprehensive reviews. After reading them (and looking at the bottles) I was tempted to get them.

Today I went down to the Montblanc boutique store and bought the 2005 and 2006 Season's Greetings, and the "Love You". I was disappointed when I learnt that they didn't have the 2007 one because the dark red looks so nice, it's my favourite colour out of the six in the reviews.

I wish I could lay my hands on a bottle of Sakura to match my Opera Club Cherry Blossom that I am going to order...crybaby.gif If only I have known of it earlier...my father went to Japan TWICE last year...I doubt he'll be going there again any time soon...

I haven't used any scented inks before, I wonder if these ones are safe with vintage pens. I have yet to try the inks because I am still looking for a suitable pen. I think I really should get a glass dip pen.
Darius
FieryPhoenix,

The inks are safe in modern pens, but I don't know about vintage. It's strange that the boutique has the older inks, but not the newer one. However, if you don't mind ordering from the US, a lot of the pen shops in there have some of these inks. The Sskura ink is quite difficult to obtain. I got it from a friend who travelled to Japan last year. It's a bit pricey though.
Stanley Lyndon
I had no idea MontBlanc made waterproof inks! That too scented?! Gosh, I need it now! Thanks a lot for the huge effort. smile.gif

P.S.: Is it possible to purchase the Season's Greeting 2007 ink anymore?
Darius
QUOTE (Stanley Lyndon @ Aug 2 2008, 12:12 AM) *
I had no idea MontBlanc made waterproof inks! That too scented?! Gosh, I need it now! Thanks a lot for the huge effort. smile.gif

Thanks for your kind words.

The Season's Greeting inks are water resistant, but they do loose a lot of their colour. So, they're not waterproof per se.
Stanley Lyndon
Darius,

As long as there is a readable remnant left, that is good enough for me. wink.gif

So, can the Season's Greetings 2007 still be purchased? If not, are there any scented inks that are at least partially waterproof?
Reginleif
If you are in the States, you can get all the Season's Greetings ink at the Montblanc Refill shop.

Darius, I must say I really love your handwriting... thank you for the reviews.

I am crossing my fingers and hoping that this year's Season's Greetings ink is "Garland Green" and smells like a [Winter Festival] Tree! thumbup.gif
Darius
QUOTE (Stanley Lyndon @ Aug 2 2008, 01:06 AM) *
Darius,

As long as there is a readable remnant left, that is good enough for me. wink.gif

So, can the Season's Greetings 2007 still be purchased? If not, are there any scented inks that are at least partially waterproof?

Sorry Stanley, I didn't see the question on your previous post.
Reginleif is right, if you are in the US you could order them from the online Montblanc Refill Shop.
You could also check if the MB boutiques still have them. Another option is the pen stores.

QUOTE (Reginleif @ Aug 2 2008, 03:36 AM) *
If you are in the States, you can get all the Season's Greetings ink at the Montblanc Refill shop.

Darius, I must say I really love your handwriting... thank you for the reviews.

I am crossing my fingers and hoping that this year's Season's Greetings ink is "Garland Green" and smells like a [Winter Festival] Tree! thumbup.gif

Reginleif, thank you for your copmliment. I also am awaiting this year's ink. It was a pleasant surprise that last year's wasn't brown again.
Darius
I forgot to mention something. Don't be mislead by the picture on the MB refill site for the Love Letter ink. They have the older one's picture, but the one they have in stock is the newer one.
Michael R.
QUOTE (Darius @ Aug 2 2008, 01:33 AM) *
I forgot to mention something. Don't be mislead by the picture on the MB refill site for the Love Letter ink. They have the older one's picture, but the one they have in stock is the newer one.



Dear Darius,

So many thanks for your comprehensive review!

Also - most important - this pointed out to me that there is a "new" 2008 version of the love letter ink I was not aware off.

I will check with my Montblanc boutique; I really hope it is available in Europe as well.

Also I'm impressed to see you owning the Japanese Special Edition. The one ink which is missing in my collection.

May I ask where you got yours from? Once in a while a bottle of this turns up on ebay for c. 60 US$ + shipping so I have passed those offers on so far...

Keep up the great work

Michael

Darius
QUOTE (Michael R. @ Aug 3 2008, 10:29 AM) *
QUOTE (Darius @ Aug 2 2008, 01:33 AM) *
I forgot to mention something. Don't be mislead by the picture on the MB refill site for the Love Letter ink. They have the older one's picture, but the one they have in stock is the newer one.



Dear Darius,

So many thanks for your comprehensive review!

Also - most important - this pointed out to me that there is a "new" 2008 version of the love letter ink I was not aware off.

I will check with my Montblanc boutique; I really hope it is available in Europe as well.

Also I'm impressed to see you owning the Japanese Special Edition. The one ink which is missing in my collection.

May I ask where you got yours from? Once in a while a bottle of this turns up on ebay for c. 60 US$ + shipping so I have passed those offers on so far...

Keep up the great work

Michael

Thank you again for your compliments.

I know what you mean about the Sakura ink. I also saw these on eBay and hesitated. I even bid on one once and lost it, because my max. bid was US$30. But I was fortunate that a friend of mine, who also uses fountain pens, visited Japan on a business trip and came back with a few bottles and some cartridges of this ink. So, I got a bottle and a couple of cartridges from him. As far as I can remember, in Japan the price was equivilant to US$32 for the bottle and US$12 for the cartridges, but memory may have failed me here. I think the running price these days is US$68 for the bottle, and US$14 for a pack of cartridges.
Darius
QUOTE (Reginleif @ Aug 2 2008, 03:36 AM) *
I am crossing my fingers and hoping that this year's Season's Greetings ink is "Garland Green" and smells like a [Winter Festival] Tree! thumbup.gif

Your wish may just come true. I was just informed that this years ink will be pine scented, or pine forest scent, but I wasn't told what the colour ir though.
Reginleif
QUOTE (Darius @ Aug 2 2008, 01:33 AM) *
I forgot to mention something. Don't be mislead by the picture on the MB refill site for the Love Letter ink. They have the older one's picture, but the one they have in stock is the newer one.


NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! I ordered two bottles! Please don't say this!!!!! When it arrives, if it's the new stuff, they're getting it back and I'm getting a refund.

QUOTE (Darius)
Your wish may just come true. I was just informed that this years ink will be pine scented, or pine forest scent, but I wasn't told what the colour ir though.


Yippie! This may make up for the Love Letter fiasco... but not a whole lot if I have to pay for postage to return this crud.
Darius
QUOTE (Reginleif @ Aug 7 2008, 09:44 AM) *
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! I ordered two bottles! Please don't say this!!!!! When it arrives, if it's the new stuff, they're getting it back and I'm getting a refund.

Yippie! This may make up for the Love Letter fiasco... but not a whole lot if I have to pay for postage to return this crud.

Well, you'll let us know if it's the new stuff or the old stuff. I may be mistaking.

The new ink will be available this fall. I hate it when they give you a broad time frame.
Reginleif
QUOTE (Darius @ Aug 7 2008, 12:59 AM) *
QUOTE (Reginleif @ Aug 7 2008, 09:44 AM) *
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! I ordered two bottles! Please don't say this!!!!! When it arrives, if it's the new stuff, they're getting it back and I'm getting a refund.

Yippie! This may make up for the Love Letter fiasco... but not a whole lot if I have to pay for postage to return this crud.

Well, you'll let us know if it's the new stuff or the old stuff. I may be mistaking.

The new ink will be available this fall. I hate it when they give you a broad time frame.



It is, indeed, the new stuff. sad.gif I wanted the old stuff.

Now I have two bottles of the stuff. :/
Stani
cool info. never knew MB made that stuff. COOOOOL.

Had to buy some right away. Love the fact that MB has a website that works for folks in Canada. thumbup.gif


............Stani
Darius
QUOTE (Reginleif @ Aug 25 2008, 03:19 AM) *
QUOTE (Darius @ Aug 7 2008, 12:59 AM) *
QUOTE (Reginleif @ Aug 7 2008, 09:44 AM) *
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! I ordered two bottles! Please don't say this!!!!! When it arrives, if it's the new stuff, they're getting it back and I'm getting a refund.

Yippie! This may make up for the Love Letter fiasco... but not a whole lot if I have to pay for postage to return this crud.

Well, you'll let us know if it's the new stuff or the old stuff. I may be mistaking.

The new ink will be available this fall. I hate it when they give you a broad time frame.



It is, indeed, the new stuff. sad.gif I wanted the old stuff.

Now I have two bottles of the stuff. :/

Sorry to hear that my friend. It is more difficult to get the old one these days. But it is still available in some places.
Darius
QUOTE (Stani @ Aug 25 2008, 04:11 AM) *
cool info. never knew MB made that stuff. COOOOOL.

Had to buy some right away. Love the fact that MB has a website that works for folks in Canada. thumbup.gif


............Stani

Yeah, collectors and users in North America are lucky
DilettanteG
Thanks so much for posting these wonderful scans and reviews! They are absolutely amazing. I'm really impressed that you've aquired the Sakura ink. $68/bottle is at least double my price threshold, so this is as close to it as I will ever get. Thanks too for the heads up on the Pine ink. I'll have to keep an eye open for it.

Do you work for Montblanc, or are you just their #1 customer? I hope they comp you if it's the latter. You're their one man ink marketing department.
Darius
QUOTE (DilettanteG @ Sep 2 2008, 09:27 PM) *
Thanks so much for posting these wonderful scans and reviews! They are absolutely amazing. I'm really impressed that you've aquired the Sakura ink. $68/bottle is at least double my price threshold, so this is as close to it as I will ever get. Thanks too for the heads up on the Pine ink. I'll have to keep an eye open for it.

Do you work for Montblanc, or are you just their #1 customer? I hope they comp you if it's the latter. You're their one man ink marketing department.

Thank you for your compliments. The Sakura is truely expensive. I think it retailed for about US$32 in Japan when it was released. But of course its exlusivity pushed up the price. The pine ink will be available in the coming weeks, or months. I can't remember when last years was released, but I think it was the end of November.
I don't work for MB, just a customer. I am obsessed with scented inks. I also have the Herbin Les Subtiles and some De Atrimentis. Of course with the latter, it is very difficult to keep up with collecting all their inks.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.