Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Esterbrook SJ 9128 Nib
The Fountain Pen Network > Reviews and Articles > Fountain Pen Reviews
vermiculus
There was a request for reviews of Esterbrook renew-point nibs a while back, and now I have access to a scanner I thought I'd oblige with a review of my favouite Estie renew point - the 9128 Extra flexibile extra fine. I won't try to put numbers to it, as I find scoring pens a little worthless, but I will do my best to explain the thing.


First Impressions

Everyone Loves Esterbrooks. I don't think you can see a J series in the flesh without falling in love with their looks and their somewhat dated post-war look - bubbly circles and clean lines make it as distinctive as the Parker 51. The Esterbrook Pen company is a good example of a company which survived the technology leap from dip to fountain, but unfortunately they lost out to the biro. I received this pen uninked as a lucky eBay find, and it felt just like I'd bought it from the shop in a time warp! I have now had two pens New Old Stock, and I find that I have a special affinity to them as their first user.

Appearance and Finish.
What a looker! The marbled finish on the J series is wonderful, but the "Dubonnet Red" must surely be the finest of them all. On top of that, I polished mine up with Renaissance Wax and it's so shiny that the magpies eye it through the window. The smallish 9128 nib suits the SJ, and when I put a 2668 into it once it looked oversized for the pen.

Design/size/weight.
I've tabulated the measurements in the writing sample, below. The pen is small in the hand, and very light - I think these are celluloid rather than plastic. This is the spoon-headed style of lever, and is a double-jewel type body. Even though it's small, I don't find it uncomfortable to use - and I usually shy away from smaller pens.

Nib
The real point of the review! (yes, pun intended).

The 9128 is a respectable flexi. It can do copperplate elegantly, and the steel construction means it's virtually indestructable. Mine was a little scratchy out of the box - it is very fine, after all - but soon relaxed after a bit of a flex workout. The line is medium-wet, and it doesn't deposit blobs at the flex, like some pens do. All in all, very satisfactory!

Here, I will post the writing sample to demonstrate performance:

Filling System
A Flawless lever filler. Indeed, these fillers are very robust and rarely do sacs need replacing, in my experience.

Cost/value
These can be had for between £10 and £20 ($20 - $40) depending on condition. I absolutely think that a good condition J series with a 9xxx nib is worth $40, though some might disagree.

Overall - This nib is a lot of fun to use, and was my first proper flex nib. Though I now have several Flexies, this remains one of my favourites. The pen itself is a joy to use.


Thanks for reading - this is my first review, so feedback is appreciated!
Murderface
Nicely done, both with the find and the review! I really like having a full review along with a scan of the pen in action. I've gotten all my birthday presents already, so I guell I'll just have to put an Estie on my X-mas list...
Reginleif
QUOTE(vermiculus @ Jul 8 2008, 03:01 PM) [snapback]664092[/snapback]
Cost/value
These can be had for between £10 and £20 ($20 - $40) depending on condition. I absolutely think that a good condition J series with a 9xxx nib is worth $40, though some might disagree.

Overall - This nib is a lot of fun to use, and was my first proper flex nib. Though I now have several Flexies, this remains one of my favourites. The pen itself is a joy to use.


Thanks for reading - this is my first review, so feedback is appreciated!


I can't find the nibs anywhere right now less than $45. sad.gif Let alone adding a pen to that...
vermiculus
Yeah, getting the nibs can be pricey. In fact, I paid about $20 for this, but it was in a bad eBay listing - I never knew I'd be getting such a goodun.

In fact, on eBay I find the pens go for less than the nibs! You could always try a Want-to-buy here...

QUOTE(Reginleif @ Jul 8 2008, 11:40 PM) [snapback]664125[/snapback]
I can't find the nibs anywhere right now less than $45. sad.gif Let alone adding a pen to that...


QUOTE
I'll just have to put an Estie on my X-mas list

Might not fill up your stocking, but it might be the best thing in there! wink.gif
System of Adam
QUOTE(vermiculus @ Jul 8 2008, 06:00 PM) [snapback]664146[/snapback]
Yeah, getting the nibs can be pricey. In fact, I paid about $20 for this, but it was in a bad eBay listing - I never knew I'd be getting such a goodun.

In fact, on eBay I find the pens go for less than the nibs! You could always try a Want-to-buy here...

QUOTE(Reginleif @ Jul 8 2008, 11:40 PM) [snapback]664125[/snapback]
I can't find the nibs anywhere right now less than $45. sad.gif Let alone adding a pen to that...


QUOTE
I'll just have to put an Estie on my X-mas list

Might not fill up your stocking, but it might be the best thing in there! wink.gif


Do you have a 9028 for comparison sake? I have 4 9028 with one of them coming back from Pendemonium after smoothing and I'd love to know how this nib stacks up...

Great Review! Thank you

Adam
vermiculus
QUOTE(System of Adam @ Jul 9 2008, 12:12 AM) [snapback]664154[/snapback]
Do you have a 9028 for comparison sake? I have 4 9028 with one of them coming back from Pendemonium after smoothing and I'd love to know how this nib stacks up...

Great Review! Thank you

Adam

'fraid not - Wish I did! I should imagine that instead of just under 0.5mm to 1.1mm, it will be maybe 0.7 to 1.5mm - but that's a complete guess. I would also expect it to be easier to flex, too.

The only nibs I have tried are 9550, 9128 and 2668.
wvbeetlebug
Whee! What fun! I really need to get a flexible nib.
lovemy51
i bought that same exact pen a few months ago for only $10 USD... alas! no flex nib crybaby.gif

Reginleif is right. those nibs go for about $45-50, so i think you got it for a very good price!

nice review... enjoy your pen!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.