Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Comparison of Purples
The Fountain Pen Network > Reviews and Articles > Ink Reviews > Ink Comparisons, Scans and Tests
JDlugosz
Another FPN member send me some writing samples, and I performed a Calibrated Scan and color analysis.

The files I present have calibrated correct values in the file, with an embedded ICC profile for Adobe RGB. You should be able to compare any of my review scans side-by-side to see the difference, because the exposure and adjustment is exactly the same in each ink scan. To aid color perception on your monitor, there is a thin white border to show the paper color (the paper is faintly blue in sunlight) and a gray matte. The matte is perfectly neutral, so judge the color relative to that.








You can see from the Color Picker views that the first two are indeed similar in Hue, being in the blue area toward the magenta edge. But the third is different, being on the other side of the magenta band between magenta and violet. My previous test of Tulipe Noire was darker and more Violet, but I noted that the Hue varied from 320 where it was light to 343 where it went on wet, so it varies in hue not just in brightness variations. That would make this an interestingly expressive ink, which does not show up on the samples I've seen or my own writing. Someone should do some calligraphy with FPN Tulipe Noire and have it scanned, so we can see how the flourishes vary from magenta to violet as they go from light to dark.

Anyway, another ink in the same Hue family as Tulipe Noire would be PR Black Cherry after it's gone stale! My database doesn't have much in it yet, so I can't say what else is close.

As for the others, Waterman Purple would fall just before the first of the three in the order shown, and PR Burg. Mist would fall between the first two and the last about mid-way.

--John

These images are hosted on my site, only to relieve the server burden. I specifically grant the right of FPN to re-host them, back them up, or otherwise to maintain continuity of this content, as they see fit.


purpledog
Thanks for the purple ink reviews. Just looking at purple makes me happy. smile.gif

purpledog
JDlugosz
QUOTE(purpledog @ Jun 26 2008, 11:10 PM) [snapback]652599[/snapback]
Thanks for the purple ink reviews. Just looking at purple makes me happy. smile.gif


how many different purple inks do you have?
purpledog
Not too many. I am moving so I am restricting myself on inks. smile.gif It's just that purple is my fav color.

purpledog
encremental
Great work, John!

Caran d'Ache Storm is one of my very favourite inks, but an extremely subtle and complicated colour - and on my monitor your scan has nailed it precisely! Of course, this means that I now know exactly what Purple Martin and Tulipe Noire look like as well, and have another two inks to buy ...

I think that Diamine's new 'Damson' is going to make a lot of purple fanciers' hearts beat faster. Definitely in Storm territory, but with even more of that dusty grey haze to it that makes Storm so appealing. Then you've got the usual great Diamine qualities as well. Maybe I'll try my hand at a review over the weekend.

John
JFT
Thank you for the comparison!

Now I have to get Tulipe Noire wub.gif
KCat
Thanks so much, John. Very interesting.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.