Good morning,

I want submit to the attention of some expert one pen that one of my friend want to sell me, it is a Montblanc Rouge et Noir made near 1915-1920, and in th nib are the number 2.

Someone can help to know the corret model of this pen..?? And how much are his value...??

I have found one at this link for 4000 USD (the first in the list):

Pen's link

But this pen have a broken cap, mine is in perfect condition and the value is more high...??

I attached some picture about the pen purpose to me.

I wait help from some expert in vintage pens.

Thank's to all,

Juri

Hi Juri,

The prices on the penomania.com page are impertinent high, much too high. Take off at least 50% and you have the realistic values.

From the pictures of "your" pen I can see that the pen has some discoloring and some signs of use. But if there are no cracks, chips or scratches and the mechanic works fine 2000.00 US$ might be OK, I wouldn't pay much more.

Axel

Thank's Axel,

my firend ask me 500 euro... is a good price...!!

The pen needs a restore, but your quote is for 1500 euro.... 500 is a good price...

Thank's,

Juri

With 500.00 Euros you can't do anything wrong!

Axel

Funny,

You should take a look what a modern version sells for at Ebay Italy. Look at this Seems to me that the real thing should sell for more than the figures mentionned above ?

Ruud

Hi Ruud,

Yes, that is funny!
But let me ask the question what would you be willing to pay for the original one from 1908, the very first fountain pen made by the Simplo Filler Pen Company?
http://www.fountainpen.de/old-rouge-et-noir-no2.htm

Regards,
Axel

Sigh, any of these pens are way beyond what I can afford... Drool, drool, drool

I personally would totally love to have one of the new ones shiny, new, vibrant colors lool

Its nice to have an antique form 1908 but for that kind of money I would go for the replica

Totaly agree,I'd go for the new version too.

I thonk that the new version it will cost more than an old Rouge et Noir....

The new version is limited at 100 pieces in the world and it is very very very expensive...!!!

I think that an oldwill be more cheap....