QUOTE(sumgaikid @ Mar 30 2008, 04:50 PM) [snapback]562579[/snapback]
QUOTE(david i @ Mar 30 2008, 07:03 PM) [snapback]562477[/snapback]
QUOTE
How so??? I used the information about the set I was given here.
I am guessing this is why it is referred to as a combination 14k gold pen and pencil set.It is not so referred and LBpens corrected this earlier. Indeed John's comment was made seemingly before it was even clear the pen was a mix. " It is the more expensive version of the Skyline in that it is a 14k gold combination." references presence of 14k on the pen, not the mismatch, and is not formal jargon anyway- though on that latter point, there would be no way for you to know.
The pen appears to be a mismatch. A frankenpen. Something of a disaster, really, as far as pens go. There is no term in pendom as "combination" aside from a derivative of this word for item that has pen and pencil in one unit.
Your ad and approach are serving as an example primarily of what serious pen collectors avoid. That too has value. Still, whilst i rarely advocate removal of threads, if it were not the benefit this thread serves to illustrate well the abuses that exist in the hobby, i would not mind seeing it go. The educational value though has merit.
regards
david
David,
By taking a quick glance at the pic as it was scrolling down my monitor I immediately could tell that it was a 14k Skyline;had I taken a better look at the pic(by blowing it up)I would have notified her that she had a combo or frankenpen. The sad part in my mind,is her reluctance to see that she did anything wrong by rewording statements from FPNers here(basically intellectual theft)to use for her own financial gain and then BARELY admitting any wrongdoing. I also worded my statement in a general fashion intentionally to avoid the impression of any specific model--I'm human and can miss important details.
My kudos to you,mandragoru,and LBpens for catching the situation and making the right judgements.
John
You are human? Welcome to the club

At least, i believe the three of us you cite are members too. Well, maybe.
Idunno. I was just left with a bad feeling about how this played out. The issue for me was not so much about a detail about a pen- that's what we play here to learn. In fact, i too might've missed the mixed parts issue save for seeing Lynn's comments. The bad feeling about the thread stemmed more about the "hidden agenda" thing. What's so hard about saying, "Hey, i found a pen, i would like to put it on ebay, can you help me with info" and then waiting a bit to get some solid answers.
d