QUOTE(Melnicki @ Feb 1 2008, 10:38 PM) [snapback]500107[/snapback]
A book has a holy status, and transcends humanity because many have outlasted lifetimes, if cherished or cared for. Many persons find highlighting or annotating a book (with a permanent ink!) to be a crime against these wonderful creatures. You may avow that the book is only for your use, but what about the person after you? What makes you so bold as to assert certain lines as prominent? Transplant them in a lovely notebook, a quotebook, or use a light pencil in the margin, my dear friends.
I won't even think about writing in library books or else I'll unleash a tirade. I smolder and fume every time I see a library book abused...
On the contrary, take your Golden Pigs for a trot across a printout, a newspaper. But evade volumes!
Of course one does not deface a library book or a book that belongs to another person.
As one who buys the books he reads, I have no hesitation highlighting, making marginal notes, etc. After all, there are many other copies of the original and the book at hand is hardly sacred.
I once took a Stalin biographer to the Marx-Engels-Lenin Institute in Moscowm (when it was still the Soviet Union) and witnessed his request to see Stalin's library. The reaon was that he wanted to see the sort of books Stalin read and, especially, to see his marginal notations. His request was denied, but now the Stalin archives are being published by Yale University Press and things like marginal notes are extremely interesting--and revealing.
The point is that books are objects that one can converse with. Obviously, you don't deface one that doesn't belong to you, but if you own it, there is nothing wrong with highlighting, marginal noting, arguing with the author. That's why I keep a couple of Preppys handy as I read books before I go to sleep. I highlight, I comment, I underline, I note on the inside back cover page numbers containing quotations that I may wish to refer to later. Maybe it's just me, but I remember passages better if I take the trouble to highlight them or to comment on the margins.
The question is not whether one marks in books but whether one respects the property of others. So long as you own the book, it's up to you what you do with it!
P.S. I wouldn't mark up a Gutenberg Bible even if I owned it. But that's a different question.