Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment
Click to view attachment

I wrote that this was a "bulletproof" ink in the handwritten review; however, I see that it is listed as "near-bulletproof."

--Lorie

Lorie:

Thank you for the thorough review. I have been thinking about buying a bottle of this ink for some time, and your review has pushed me to do it. I have been looking for a blue-black that is "black with a slight blue hint" and this seems to be what I was looking for. Again, thank you for taking the time to post this.


Dave

So glad you found it helpful! You're very welcome.

--Lorie

The broader the point on the nib, the more blue in this ink you'll see on paper (my experience). This seems to be the experience reported around here with many blue-black inks.

Thank you for the review.

I know I am colour blind but I am seeing some green in that colour. Anyone else?




Mame

Very nice review, thanks.

I don't see much green in the scans above, but I have seen green in other writing samples using this ink. That doesn't surprise me, because all of Noodler's blue blacks have some amount of green in them.

Strongly seconded - I carry an address book around, really a Clairefontaine 3.5" by 5.5" ruled notebook, that I filled out with Blue-Black and a Medium Phileas. There's a lot of shading present, and the blue-black character is much more pronounced. I don't see any green shades, either - if anything, the tint's a very cool blue.

Jon

Thanks for your review. Noodler's blue-black is one of my favorite inks, and definitely my favorite blue-black ink.

GD~

Noodlers blue-blacks is one of the inks I have that I just haven't been able to warm up to. I may give it another shot, mixed with some Iraqi indigo to steer away from the green.

Stephen

Thanks for the review. Noodler's B-B is one of my favorites -- well, I should say "was". That bottle is gone, and now I'm working my way through a bottle of Ellis Island, which is similar.

I got a (Pear Tree) sample of this. I prioritized the 4 samples with a dip pen, and didn't initially like this. It's turn to be tried in a "real" pen finally came, and I've warmed to it somewhat.

It is certainly at the black end of blue-black. You almost need a black reference on the page to tell it ISN'T black (or bright light). But it stands as as "original" on a page with black text so it could be a signature ink. Droplets of water will smudge the blue, but a wash in running water removes the blue quite completely, leaving black. The "black" is of course diluted and more of a (very) dark gray but very legible. The color change clearly shows it has been "washed" which might be a good thing.

When diluted, it is clear the "blue" component leans a little green, probably less than other Noodler blues. I wish the blueness stood out a little more. I prefer the color of PR Midnight Blues, which, to me, is at the blue end of blue black, but it has no permanence. I'm still trying to decide whether to buy a bottle.

That's what I thought until I did this test (scroll up here for the pre-soak scan). As the picture shows, there is some permanence there.