The only time I have found condensation inside my cap or on my nib is from not
putting it in my shirt pocket and walking around at work with it my hand where my
body heat is warming up the pen causing a rainforest effect in side the cap, after
all it is humid in the pen with water being the biggest ingredient of ink.
It seems like after you put your cap on your pen it gets close enough to a heat
source; under a lamp, sunlight thru a window etc. where it can form condensation
and it only needs to be a few degrees higher than the temp of the rest of the room.
Just a thought.
Also, tightening your cap is not going to fix it. If it were the cap not being tight you
would get a dry nib or maybe a hard starter, not a wet inside cap unless it's stored
in a humidor or you take a shower with it.
Scott.