[Shinchan]

Review of Montblanc Thomas Mann Writer's Edition 2009 - Broad Nib

The brilliance of Paul Thomas Mann, born 6 June 1875 in Lübeck, was already evident in his early creative phase: he demonstrated flashes of genius in his prose sketches and essays whilst still a schoolboy, before signing a letter with “Thomas Mann. Lyrical dramatic poet” at the age of just 14. He was, however, to be proved right: he had barely begun as a trainee in an insurance company when he made his writing debut with the published novella “Gefallen”, which earned him widespread acclaim. Encouraged by this critical success, Mann decided to commit to a career as a writer.In 1901, aged just 26, he completed his famous family saga “Buddenbrooks”, a masterpiece of linguistic artistry and cunning irony. This epic novel, translated into over 40 languages, has cast its spell over more than 6 million readers to date. The novel won its author the 1929 Nobel Prize for Literature. Thomas Mann’s masterpiece “Buddenbrooks” has brought him immortality and has turned him into one of the most famous writers of the 20th century. Montblanc is paying tribute to this unique wordsmith with an equally unique Writers Edition.

http://lh6.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/Suuv8izsyyI/AAAAAAAAA18/-oKG67uAmGQ/s800/Thomas%20Mann.jpg


First Impressions (9/10)

The box comes in the shape of a book, which is nothing new for a typical Writer’s Edition pen, but a refreshing change for someone like me who has yet to own any W.E. My first impression of the cover design was that it very much resembled a printed circuit board from the way the black lines run on the dark blue background.

http://lh6.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPkzIR-v5I/AAAAAAAAAx4/fsr6b0NMm6g/s800/P1010891.JPG

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPk3KvhyjI/AAAAAAAAAx8/QkGfO5e-NfI/s800/P1010892.JPG

Montblanc Thomas Mann Writer's Edition 2009 Information:

Launch: 2009
Limitation:
12,000 fountain pens
15,000 ballpoint pens
6,000 rollerballs
3,000 sets comprising fountain pen, ballpoint pen and mechanical pencil

Appearance & Design (10/10)

http://lh4.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPk7Gz0GSI/AAAAAAAAAyA/LQCm4pI-nO4/s800/P1010894.JPG

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPk_YaUU0I/AAAAAAAAAyI/sCh4qBlvndc/s800/P1010895.JPG


I like the lustrous glow of rich black the pen emits. It mesmerizes and draws you into a maze of rich black and platinum. The pen has an avant garde design, with it’s barrel coated with precious black & rich lacquer while at the same time segmented by an array of multi-layered platinum Inlays. The theme of this design is inspired by the age of artistic creativity in which Thomas Mann lived: the Art Deco era. Lacquer, especially Chinese lacquer & Urushi, had always been the forte of S.T. Dupont and well known Japanese pen manufacturers such as Namiki & Danitrio. Using lacquer as the theme of the 2009 W.E is an excellent idea, since it’s a highly resistant, strong and beautiful material to work with. The lacquer work is flawless, since the lacquer blended perfectly with the platinum inlays.

http://lh4.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPnjln6K5I/AAAAAAAAA0k/8wMX9cRbZj0/s800/P1010936.JPG

The onyx-coloured zircon set above the teardrop on the platinum clip simply adds more depth to the polished black and platinum facet of the pen.

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPlCR3kCqI/AAAAAAAAAyM/tquazYUCdS4/s800/P1010896.JPG

http://lh3.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPlG1YwLXI/AAAAAAAAAyQ/9vsjXPoeLF4/s800/P1010897.JPG


Comparison with S.T. Dupont XL Olympio Chinese Lacquer with Palladium Trim


There is no discernible difference between the lacquer work of both the Thomas Mann and the S.T. Dupont XL Olympio. Both pens’ lacquer coatings share the same characteristics – deep, rich and black sheen that can only come from the Rhus Vernicifera lacquer, and feels great in hand.

http://lh3.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPoAfGqIUI/AAAAAAAAA1A/HeiZqIQ0wj8/s800/P1010944.JPG

http://lh4.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPoHoG6DtI/AAAAAAAAA1M/S01DEUL5kck/s800/P1010946.JPG


The pen’s cap is dome shaped, which is similar to Montblanc safety fillers dating from post World War 1 era. The cap bears a close resemblance of the Dickens W.E’s cap as well. The Montblanc emblem is Ivory colored, which gives the pen a nice vintage touch.

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPmdCVRuMI/AAAAAAAAAzw/kKm_70pQ2bM/s800/P1010923.JPG

http://lh3.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPlyvh12kI/AAAAAAAAA2s/-vbnkTykDVU/s800/P1010907.JPG

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPlmwi6E2I/AAAAAAAAAyw/GDAp1u2X810/s800/P1010904.JPG

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPlhwIGafI/AAAAAAAAA3w/i_gZmzbk_z0/s800/P1010903.JPG


One thing that I have always admired about German and Japanese manufacturers in general is their absolute, tenacious dedication to Six Sigma i.e quality as well as precision. With this Thomas Mann W.E, there is no exception. When I screw/unscrew the pen, there is no wobbling or tightness at all, the tolerance between the cap’s and barrel’s screw thread is minimal. Just the kind of German precision to expect from Montblanc. The spring loaded pen cap screws on firmly, and an extra twist is required to screw the cap fully. When the cap is fully screwed on, the platinum inlays on the barrel are precisely aligned with the similar inlays on the cap. This sounds simple, but it’s a feat that can only achieved by solid quality control, which is found very lacking in certain well established manufacturers of Italian origin.

http://lh6.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPl4zdrq-I/AAAAAAAAAzI/l_VqFPbpx2I/s800/P1010909.JPG


Weight & Dimensions (10/10)


Weighing 57.5 grams and at 140 mm long, this is a full bodied fountain pen with a solid heft. I would suppose the pen has a lacquer over metal construction in order to account for the weight.

http://lh4.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPl0689ufI/AAAAAAAAAzE/cOUwYcFaCCo/s800/P1010908.JPG


Comparison with Montblanc UNICEF Signature for Good Meisterstück 146 Le Grand


The Thomas Mann’s cap clearly has a thicker girth than the UNICEF Le Grand, while the Le Grand is slightly longer at 146 mm due to it’s torpedo design as opposed to the Thomas Mann flat bottom.

http://lh6.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPntn34aKI/AAAAAAAAA0s/tQ5MlR5oPrQ/s800/P1010939.JPG

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPnxz6ax0I/AAAAAAAAA0w/p3t_nmGfffI/s800/P1010940.JPG

http://lh6.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPlUhAciLI/AAAAAAAAAyg/O-4RBjqkD7k/s800/P1010900.JPG

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPlddXQd0I/AAAAAAAAAyo/XYftqtPD0hg/s800/P1010902.JPG


Nib & Performance (9.5/10)


The nib is a rhodium-plated 18 K gold Broad, which blends very well with the black and platinum facet of the pen. The “Buddenbrooks” house is delicately engraved on the nib’s surface.

http://lh3.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuRHRsGknrI/AAAAAAAAA1g/y5fDaloGBKQ/s800/P1010952.JPG

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPmQBxxpII/AAAAAAAAAzk/5alqSzxzL14/s800/P1010915.JPG

http://lh4.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPmZVIHRUI/AAAAAAAAAzs/FAFn8tQy8oo/s800/P1010922.JPG

http://lh3.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPnGdoOt4I/AAAAAAAAA0M/HK9tk1h34F0/s800/P1010928.JPG

http://lh4.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPnQUR7bUI/AAAAAAAAA0U/OlphPoJRev8/s800/P1010929.JPG

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPnoTWgZoI/AAAAAAAAA0o/AjknUHaOtMw/s800/P1010937.JPG


The nib starts putting ink right from the get go without skipping and is glass smooth. The only complaint that I have is the stiffness of the nib. If only Montblanc can produce nibs with the same kind of flex exhibited by older vintage Montblanc pieces! It writes with stubbish qualities, which are synonymous with the Broad and Oblique Broad nibs of the Montblanc Meisterstück 149. Only one word can aptly sum up the writing experience – BLISS.

A writing sample of the broad nib as follows:


http://lh4.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuQClutBjiI/AAAAAAAAA1U/tI1ajQaJfrk/s800/P1010949.JPG


Coincidentally, my Broad and Ghost Plane’s Broad comes with serial numbers close to the tail end of 12,000, and based on initial sampling i.e PenTieRun’s and goodguy’s Fines are numbered 5xxx & 6xxx, I am speculating that Montblanc is allocating the serial numbers based on the Thomas Mann nib size.

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPlu586SKI/AAAAAAAAA38/GnR77jS7oCA/s800/P1010906.JPG


For those who are interested, please read on for an introduction of the history of “Buddenbrooks” house.

“Buddenbrooks” House

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuRGiKxQn4I/AAAAAAAAA1c/SIEKp0I31CE/s800/Buddenbrooks%20House.jpg


The Buddenbrooks House at Mengstrasse 4, opposite St. Mary’s Church, has a chequered history: The house was built by Johann Michael Croll, a merchant from Marburg, in 1758 and was bought by Johann Siegmund Mann, the grandfather of Heinrich and Thomas Mann, in 1841. The Mann family owned the property until 1891. In 1893 the Hanseatic City of Lübeck took over the building and subsequently rented it out. As a result the house that literature had made famous became, amongst other things, the land registry office, a night station for lantern keepers as well as the headquarters of the Lübeck State Lottery. When the “Buddenbrook Bookshop” was opened in 1922, an event attended by Thomas Mann, the intention was to make the house at least accessible to literature.


In the night before Palm Sunday 1942 RAF bombardments destroyed more than a fifth of the historic Old Town of Lübeck. Of the Buddenbrook House only the façade and the vaulted cellar remained. In 1954 a bank purchased the destroyed property and erected a new building behind the old façade, opening a branch there in 1957.


In 1991 the Buddenbrooks House, made famous by Thomas Mann’s novel, was returned to the possession of the Hanseatic City of Lübeck, with the assistance of the Federal Republic of Germany and the state of Schleswig-Holstein. A modern Heinrich and Thomas Mann Centre was erected behind the original façade, to become the perfect place for an animated debate about the life and works of the two brothers. A permanent exhibition on the ground floor gives visitors insights into the relationship between these two men and between them and Lübeck, their home town. Temporary exhibitions, conferences, film and video shows, as well as readings take place on the first floor and in the vault. A research area with a library and computer centre is under construction and is intended to provide practical support for anyone interested in Heinrich and Thomas Mann.


Filling System (10/10)


http://lh6.ggpht.com/_3b0jnFyM9rc/SuPnfixAyZI/AAAAAAAAA0g/s6EOJmlDdOQ/s800/P1010935.JPG


This pen uses the piston filler, which is a plus since it can hold a more decent capacity of ink compared to CC fillers.


Conclusion - Final Score (9/10)


This is an excellent pen with an avant garde design, solid build and quality workmanship, but it comes with a hefty price tag too. Iconic? Perhaps. It would be interesting to observe how the lacquer will age with time, since lacquer is a living material. This pen will make a great addition to any collector’s prized collection, especially collectors who are interested in Lacquer or Urushi based fountain pens.

This post has been edited by Shinchan: 31 October 2009 - 01:39 PM

[waffas]

Great review! Great Pics! I do want one now! Shaw first, Mann second :)

[Fuzzyjim]

Both a beautiful pen and a beautiful review. I really enjoyed the background! Saving my money for this one!

[adam11]

Well, I like T. Mann-author a lot :)

[encre]

Simply stunning review, I never liked the angular styling of this writers edition but reading your review and watching your photographs makes me want it.

The cap is really amazing, imagine the Hemingway body Alexandre Dumas nib and this cap. wow.

This post has been edited by encre: 31 October 2009 - 05:25 PM

[dandelion]

Great photos and review. I really appreciate the background on Mann's Buddenbrook House and the writing sample. That B looks real nice and stubbish. Thank you!

[reprieve]

I am giving the Mann a second look because of this review. I thought I wasn't much interested in it, but I may have dismissed this pen too quickly.

[goodguy]

Love your review!!!
I wish I could write nice reviews as you can AND your picture taking skills are superb!!!

Good job :)

Oh and I dont need to add that I love my TM.

[georges zaslavsky]

nice review :) enjoy your pen

[Shinchan]

waffas, on 31 October 2009 - 03:42 PM, said:

Great review! Great Pics! I do want one now! Shaw first, Mann second :)

+1, though I swapped the sequence here. Handled the Shaw before, simply loved it!

Fuzzyjim, on 31 October 2009 - 04:04 PM, said:

Both a beautiful pen and a beautiful review. I really enjoyed the background! Saving my money for this one!

If you like Writer Editions with heft, you should consider the Bernard Shaw and Jules Verne too.

adam11, on 31 October 2009 - 05:00 PM, said:

Well, I like T. Mann-author a lot :)

Unfortunately, I had not read any of his works, which is really quite a shame.

encre, on 31 October 2009 - 05:22 PM, said:

The cap is really amazing, imagine the Hemingway body Alexandre Dumas nib and this cap. wow.

I like your idea. The Dumas Nib's design is fabulous. A close second will be Edgar Allan Poe's Raven nib.

reprieve, on 31 October 2009 - 06:42 PM, said:

I am giving the Mann a second look because of this review. I thought I wasn't much interested in it, but I may have dismissed this pen too quickly.

It's a well constructed pen with a superb lacquer finish which is supposedly highly resistant to scratches. The nib on this pen writes beautifully too. Would suggest you visit your local MB boutique or AD and handle this pen and get a feel of it first.

goodguy, on 31 October 2009 - 07:03 PM, said:

Love your review!!!
I wish I could write nice reviews as you can AND your picture taking skills are superb!!!

Good job :)

Oh and I dont need to add that I love my TM.

Hi Amir, thanks. Glad you enjoyed the review. I had wanted to do this review along with you previously but I had to wait for over a month for the Broad nib to be shipped. This review took me 2 weekends to complete. First weekend was for photo taking while this weekend is for penning the review. I am glad I am the next after you to post the review of this pen :) Too bad I don't have a pet to pose the pen with!

georges zaslavsky, on 31 October 2009 - 09:07 PM, said:

nice review :) enjoy your pen

Thanks georges! You too..Enjoy your pens in great health :)

[Brian]

Shinchan,

A very well done review with many photos showing to good effect the many details of this piece. It is a very sober pen and I like the comparison to ST Dupont. Among many pen manufacturers Mont Blanc seems to be unique in mastering both well done resin pens and metal based enameled pens like the Mann.

Thank you for providing this fine review. This is something that belongs in the FPN review classics!

[rokurinpapa]

Excellent review, pen and photos. I can understand the background very well. Some people say
that Montblanc have cut corners in their modern work . But I think this pen is a great work by
skilled craftsmans.Thank you for your review.

rokurinpapa

[meiers]

This is one of the most engaging and thoughtfully constructed pen reviews I have ever read.
I will definitely check out the Thomas Mann Writer's Edition.


Many thanks!
Matt

[Shinchan]

For those who are interested to know, the limit is 30 pictures per post ;)

[PigRatAndGoat]

I had dismissed the Mann as a resin based pen. Fortunately, it seems that I'm wrong. Thanks for the beautiful pictures and helping me see the light...